Battle of Liegnitz 1241

Battle description from Annals of Jan Dlugosz (translation from http://www.impub.co.uk/dlug3.html - http://www.impub.co.uk/dlug3.html)
....On April 9, Prince Henry, in splendid armour, rides out from Legnica to do battle with the Tatars. As he rides past the Church of the Blessed Virgin, a stone falls from the roof narrowly missing his head. This is regarded as a divine warning or, at least, an ill omen. The Prince arrays his army on level ground near the River Nysa in four ranks: the first consists of crusaders and volunteers speaking several languages, and some gold miners from Zlotoryja; the second line is made up of knights from Cracow and Wielkopolska; the third of knights from Opole; the fourth of the Grand Master of the Prussian Knights with his brethren and other chivalry; while the fifth consists of Silesian and Wroclavian barons, the pick of the knights from Wielkopolska and Silesia and a small contingent of mercenaries, all under the command of Prince Henry himself. There are many Tatar units, each more numerous and more experienced in battle; indeed, each consists of more men than the combined Polish force. Battle is joined.

The Poles attack first and their initial charge breaks the first Tatar rank and moves forward, but, when the fighting becomes hand-to-hand, they are surrounded by Tatar archers, who prevent the others coming to their assistance. These then waver and finally fall beneath the hail of arrows, like delicate heads of corn broken by hail-stones, for many of them are wearing no armour, and the survivors retreat. Now two Polish ranks are fighting three Tatar units; indeed, have overcome them, for the Polish crossbowmen protect them from the Tatar archers, but then someone from the Tatar ranks starts running hither and thither between the two armies shouting "Run, run!" to the Poles and encouragement to the Tatars. The Duke of Opole, thinking the shouts come from a friend, not an enemy, withdraws his men. When Prince Henry sees what is happening, he laments aloud, but brings up his fourth rank, which contains the best of his troops and with them is on the point of overcoming the Tatars, when a fourth and even larger Tatar force under Batu comes up and fighting is resumed. The Tatars attack fiercely, but the Poles refuse to retreat, and for a while honours are even.

Among the Tatar standards is a huge one with a giant X painted on it. It is topped with an ugly black head with a chin covered with hair. As the Tatars withdraw some hundred paces, the bearer of this standard begins violently shaking the great head, from which there suddenly bursts a cloud with a foul smell that envelopes the Poles and makes them all but faint, so that they are incapable of fighting. We know that in their wars the Tatars have always used the arts of divination and witch-craft, and this is what they are doing now. Seeing that the all but victorious Poles are daunted by the cloud and its foul smell, the Tatars raise a great shout and return to the fray, scattering the Polish ranks that hitherto have held firm, and a huge slaughter ensues.
Among those who fall are Boleslav the son of the Margrave of Moravia and the Master of the Prussian Order. Prince Henry does not desert his men. Surrounded by Tatars who are attacking him from all sides, he and a handful of others try to force their way through the enemy. Then, when he has almost won through and there are only four knights left with him, the Prince's horse, already wounded, drops dead. The Tatars, recognizing the Prince by his insignia, press after him. For a while he and his companions fight on; then his fourth knight brings him a fresh horse taken from the Prince's chamberlain. The Prince remounts and the five make another attempt to break through the enemy ranks; but once again are surrounded. Nonetheless they fight on. As the Prince is raising his arm to bring his sword down on an enemy, a Tatar thrusts his lance into the Prince's armpit and the Prince slides from his horse. The Tatars pounce on the Prince and, dragging him two bowshots clear, cut off his head with a sword, tear off all his badges and leave his corpse naked. In this great battle a number of the Polish nobility and gentry find honourable martyrdom in defence of their Faith. The saintly Jadwiga, then in Krosno, is informed by the Holy Spirit of the extent of the disaster and of the death of her son in the same hour as it happens, and tells this to a nun, called Adelaide.
Jan Iwanowic, the knight who brought Henry the horse that nearly saved him, joins forces with two of the shield-bearers and another knight, called Lucman, who has two servants with him and himself has twelve wounds. When their pursuers pause for a breather in a village a mile or so from the battlefield, the six turn and attack them, killing two of their number and taking one prisoner. After this, Iwanowic enters a Dominican monastery and lives there piously, grateful that the Good Lord has saved him from so many dangers.
Having collected their booty, the Tatars, wishing to know the exact number of the dead, cut one ear off each corpse, filling nine huge sacks to the brim. Then, impaling Prince Henry's head on a long lance, they approach the castle at Legnica (for the town has already been burned for fear of the Tatars) and display it for those inside to see, calling upon them through an interpreter to open the gates.

The defenders refuse, telling them that they have several other dukes, sons of good duke Henry, besides Henry. The Tatars then move on to Olomouc, where they camp for a fortnight, burning and destroying everything round about. Moving on again, they halt for a week at Bolesisko, and, after slaughtering many of the inhabitants, continue into Moravia......

Controversy about the battle

Presence of Teutons Order at Legnica
In the recent studies provided by the polish miedeval scholar Gerard Labuda, some discrepansies in Annals of Jan D³ugosz have been disovered. Initially D³ugosz specifies four polish units but when he comes to the details suddenly five units appears. Critical analyze of D³ugosz's Annals have proved that the fifth unit - Teuton Knights commanded by the Grandmaster Poppo von Ostern - have been added after the Annalas had been completed.. According to this supplement Teuton's unit has been nearly anihilated on the battlefield and the Granmaster has been killed. However according to the other sources Poppo von Ostern has been appointed to the position of Grandmaster in 1252 (11 years after the Battle). Due to the services rendered to the franciscans he has been burried (1263) in the church of St. Jacob , in which Prince Henry had been burried too. Due to this neighbourhood the legend arose that Poppo von Ostern has been killed in the battle of Legnica as well. Nevertheless the most possible theory is that Teutons (a least as separate unit) have never participated in the battle of Legnica...
The number of the warriors
For a long time scholars disagreed to the number of Mongols invaded Poland. There were similar controversies concerning the chief commander of Mongolian army. Batu and Kadaan mentioned by D³ugosz have commanded the armies in Hungary and Transylvania. Turning point in a research of this issue occurred suddenly in 1965, when unknown new source has been discovered -"Hystoria Tatarorum" by Franciscan C. de Bridia Monachi. This work has been written on the basis of the relation of Franciscans Jan de Piano Caprini and Benedict the Pole from their travel to Mongolia in 1245-47. The information from Hystoria Tartarorum is fully trustworthy since it was collected directly from Mongols participants of the battle just a few years after this battle.
"... Next Batu went to Poland and Hungary and having divided the army on the border of these two countries, he sent 10 thousands of warriors under his brother Ordu against Poland.."
So 1 tumen of Mongolian warriors commanded by Ordu took part in the invasion against Poland.
Considering the losses incurred by Mongols during the campaign (battle of Tursk, Chmielnik, siege of Cracow, Racibor and actions on Kujavia) Mongols army at Legnica could not be composed of not more than 8 thousands warriors.
The case is much more complicated when we talk about the army of Prince Henry.
Many scholars assumed the number of Christian army on the level of 30-40 thousands warriors. However this assumption is absolutely improbable. We should remember that more than 150 years later, much bigger and richer Poland has set 25-thousands army to fight with Teutons Order (Grunwald 1410). Moreover no knights from Kujawia and Mazowia have fight at Legnica, and units from Lesser Poland have been decimated after the defeats at Tursk and Chmielnik. In the present days polish warfare historians differently estimates the number of Prince Henry army. According to the Prof. Mare Cetwiñski it was about 2 thousands warriors, whereas Prof. Gerard Labuda estimates this army on the level of 7-8 thousands. Since none of the parties of the battle have prevailed during the first stage, theory of Labuda seems to be more trustworthy.
 
Reconstruction of the battle
The polish army was arranged in a following manner:
· the unit of Moravian margrave Boleslaw was the avangarde of the polish force
· the units of Sulis³aw and Opolan prince Mieszko were behind Bole³aw's unit -their  task was to protect left and right wing,
· the unit under personal command of Prince Henry constituted a reserve.

Mongolian army was divided into four units as well. In the first line there were 3 units and behind them the reserve unit commanded by Ordu himself. The Mongolian units on the right and left wing was standing in a long distance from the center unit and was hidden from the polish army sight. Probably Ordu wanted to encircle the attacking polish units by his units from the wings.

red -Poles, black - Mongols
As a first the Boles³aw's unit has rushed to the fight. Covered by the thousands of arrows it has forced his way to center Mongolian unit and has started melee combat. Then the Mongolian units from left and right wings came out of hiding and have encircled Boles³aw's unit. This unit has been nearly annihilated and margrave Boles³aw has been killed. The units of Sulislav and Prince Mieszko have assaulted being in the middle of attack Mongolian units.

Poles have broken the Mongolian formation and started to push them backward. Suddenly the polish knights have heard the voices calling to retreat in polish language and the whole unit of Prince Mieszko thinking that these voiced were coming from the friendly units has rushed to escape. The event is confirmed by "Hystoria Tartarorum"- "... when the Mongols have clashed with prince of Silesia and have been about to withdraw..Unexpectedly Christian units have started to run away.. ".
Seeing the withdrawal of prince Mieszko's unit Prince Henryk moved with his last reserve. The victory was beginning to be again in polish hands, but the Mongols had still some fresh forces - Ordu unit - and also some kind of "wunderwaffe"...

All of sudden in front of Mongols formation a horseman keeping a standard with giant X and bearded head appeared " from which there suddenly bursts a cloud with a foul smell that envelopes the Poles and makes them all but faint, so that they are incapable of fighting" Then the reserve Mongolian unit have stroke Poles deciding the battle. Prince Henry with some of his knights tried to break out trough Mongolian army but have been caught up and captured.

Afterward Henry was decapitated.. His head was sent to Batu, but before that Mongols had shown it (impaled on the spear) to defensors of Legnica, demanding to surrender. After refusal they have burnt and plunder neighboring villages. Then they rushed into direction of Otmochov.

"when a fourth and even larger Tatar force under Batu comes up and fighting is resumed."

Wasn't Batu in Hungary with Subedei????

Fist part of article is battle description from miedeval chronicle (Annals by Jan Długosz). Thus this description is innacurate in many issues. The analize of this innacurances you can find in the next chapter " Controversy about the battle".

As for Batu it is clearly stated:

and

God help me. Another warhead-like figure coming up at the other end of the scale.

By the way, it's a public secret that in the 13th century the Mongols had better discipline and a better grasp of large-scale warfare than their European opponents--the result of having spent practically the whole of the previous century in an almost endless succession of wars. Plus, the Mongol army (in this case that of Batu and the Golden Horde) wasn't strictly Mongol--remember the heavy cavalry of Khwarezm-shah and the Boyars of the Russian principalities? They were only a small sample of the great numbers of military traditions that were integrated into the Mongol war machine. They were also part of the reason why the Mongol war machine could be so versatile and so effective as long as it had a charismatic leader to hold it together. As for the defeats...well, have you ever heard of a major military power that has never faced a single defeat? Tell me if you have.

No.

Please specify this defeats...

I know of scouting forces being swamped before.

There was a battle, on a bridge I believe, or near one, where the Mongols almost lost because of the sheer numbers of Europeans pressing down on them, but Sudebei came to the rescue, like Gandalf in the Two Towers!

That's probably what it looked like, exept without a castle.

The 3 is some sort of "light" l, I believe. It's really hard to describe if you don't have a native speaker at hand. By the way, the battle TMPikachu mentioned was at the Khalkha River, in the massive reconnaisance campaign that Chinggis Khan sent of under Jebei and Subedei.

"God help me. Another warhead-like figure coming up at the other end of the scale."

Sorry, but there is nothing about me that come up at the end of scale, I promote historical accuracy not baseless biased nonsense. My argument are clearly based on sources and I will debate it with you if you need the source.

TJK-

I have a few questions about Poland vs. the Mongols and I hope you or someone else could help me out.  First of all, how did Poland's relations with the Mongols/Tartars develop from 1241 to 1410? Specifically, how did they go from bitter enemies in 1241 to allies in 1410 at the battle of Grunwald/Tannenburg?  Was there a gradual improvement in diplomatic relations after the invasions of the 1200's, and if so, how did this come about?  Did Poland develop trade relations with the Mongols?  Did any other Poles travel in the Mongol Empire other than Benedict the Pole?

Thanks in advance for any responses.

This was rather result of lithuanian activity - starting from the beigning of XIV century many Tatars was settled in the area controlled by Lithuanian Grand Dukes. Jagie³lo before beame the polish king was the ally of Golden Horde and his army marched to help Mamaj against Muscovites during the battle of Kulikovo Polje. In the time of Grunwald, Grand Duke Witold (Vytautas) was supported by Jellal-ad din the son of the former khan Tohtamysh who have been expelled from Golden Horde by Tamerlane.

I don't know many about trades between Poland nad Golden Horde but such relation exist for sure.     

TMPikachu Quote: "There was a battle, on a bridge I believe, or near one, where the Mongols almost lost because of the sheer numbers of Europeans pressing down on them, but Sudebei came to the rescue, like Gandalf in the Two Towers!

That's probably what it looked like, exept without a castle."

Me: Yes, in Hungary at a bridge on the Sajo River. Good allusion to Gandalf in Two Towers.

The Mongol army was made entirely out of horsemen.They were always moving and the enemy thought they were outnumbered.But Mongol armies were often smaller than their enemies.

So you know more about Poland then me  

I think this is regarding the Lajkonik celebration in Kraków (it is held every year 8 days after Corpus Christi), but in fact this about quite other Tatar expedition which take place in 1287

Right, thus only one tumen was directed to attack Poland

Originally posted by TJK I think this is regarding the Lajkonik celebration in Kraków (it is held every year 8 days after Corpus Christi), but in fact this about quite other Tatar expedition which take place in 1287

Sorry for answering so late, but this maybe can explain it... according what you have said, the following link information is probably wrong. In case you want to read it...

  http://forums.civfanatics.com/showpost.php?p=1104236&postcount=2 - http://forums.civfanatics.com/showpost.php?p=1104236&pos tcount=2

Yeah, this is wrong - even the date of celebration (in fact 8 days after Corpus Chisti in June).

Lajkonik celebrates the legaendary triumph of a brave bargeman, over Han, chief of the invading Tatars in the in the year 1287. Upon learning of Han’s death, his Tatars lost their fighting spirit and fled Krakow. In joyous celebration, the brave bargeman dressed himself as Han and triumphantly rode into Krakow with his men to the ovation of all. The people of Krakow nicknamed him Lajkonik.

It should be mentioned however that this tradition is quite new - the first celebration is recorded in 1738 and the legend is described first time in 1820..so in fact we don't know the real roots of this ceremony