Author |
Share Topic Topic Search Topic Options
|
Cyrus Shahmiri
Administrator
King of Kings
Joined: 07-Aug-2004
Location: Iran
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 6240
|
Quote Reply
Topic: Suggest words for non-IE English words Posted: 29-Oct-2004 at 04:04 |
English is an Indo-European language but there are some non-IE words in this language, for example the English word "camel" has a semetic origin, it comes from Arabic "Jamal", Hebrew "Gamal", Assyrian "Gumla", Akkadian "Gammalu", ... but the Avestan/Sanskrit word for camel is "Ushtra" (like "Zaraushtra" = Zoroaster [Loving the camel]), so what should be the English word for it? Is there something like Ushtra in other European languages?
|
|
|
hansioux
Colonel
Joined: 16-Aug-2004
Location: Taiwan
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 537
|
Quote Reply
Posted: 29-Oct-2004 at 04:14 |
Originally posted by Cyrus Shahmiri
English is an Indo-European language but there are some non-IE words in this language, for example the English word "camel" has a semetic origin, it comes from Arabic "Jamal", Hebrew "Gamal", Assyrian "Gumla", Akkadian "Gammalu", ... but the Avestan/Sanskrit word for camel is "Ushtra" (like "Zaraushtra" = Zoroaster [Loving the camel]), so what should be the English word for it? Is there something like Ushtra in other European languages? |
Well, first of all... there aren't any camels in England. So when the language was developing, the word of camel must have been introduced when English people were able to travel to the middle east. Besides, the use of camel as transportation is a later discovery than horses right?
Much like even though Taiwanese aboriginals are part of Austronesians, however since most of highland tribes never sailed the oceans, they lacked the common root words of those seafaring Austronesians.
|
Begging plea of the weak can only receive disrespect, violence and oppression as bestowments. Blood and sweat of the weak can only receive insult, blame and abuse as rewards.
Lai Ho, Formosan Poet
|
|
Sharrukin
Chieftain
Joined: 04-Aug-2004
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 1314
|
Quote Reply
Posted: 31-Oct-2004 at 22:24 |
Hmmm, yes. A natual English word for "camel" could only have occurred either by defusion from another IE culture familiar with them, or by borrowing from a non-IE culture familiar with them. In the case of "camel" there is no original IE word, but a borrowing from either an unattested or extinct central Asian language (for the Bactrian camel) or a Semitic language (for the dromedary). The immediate predecessors to speakers of English were those speaking a western Germanic dialect from a region in northern Europe where camels were definitely not native. Of IE cultures, the only ones which would have been in regions where the camel exist (central Asia and northeastern Iran) where the Bactrian camel lives would have been either Indo-Iranian or Tocharian, and since the word "camel" was not part of the original IE vocabulary, their word may have come from a non-IE source.
|
|
Guests
Guest
|
Quote Reply
Posted: 31-Oct-2004 at 23:19 |
..the English word "camel" has a semetic origin, it comes from Arabic "Jamal", Hebrew "Gamal", Assyrian "Gumla", Akkadian "Gammalu" |
So when the language was developing, the word of camel must have been introduced when English people were able to travel to the middle east. |
I think English word "Camel" is a Latin/Greek loan word. But as you said it's of a semitic origin.
Kamelos - in Greek Camelus - in Latin Cameil - in Old English, Anglo-Norman
In the case of "camel" there is no original IE word, but a borrowing from either an unattested or extinct central Asian language (for the Bactrian camel) or a Semitic language (for the dromedary). |
What do you think about Persian word for camel "Shotor"? Is it of IE origin or was it borrowed as well?
Edited by Elteber
|
|
Serge L
Baron
Joined: 03-Aug-2004
Location: Italy
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 485
|
Quote Reply
Posted: 01-Nov-2004 at 08:13 |
Analogously, I suppose other words referred to things that do not exist in England or Europe (e.g. Igloo, Kangaroo, etc.) are not IE.
|
|
Sharrukin
Chieftain
Joined: 04-Aug-2004
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 1314
|
Quote Reply
Posted: 01-Nov-2004 at 09:02 |
What do you think about Persian word for camel "Shotor"? Is it of IE origin or was it borrowed as well? |
Probably borrowed. The more ancient Avestan (Eastern Iranian) and Sanskrit (Indo-Aryan) word for camel was ushtra (of which shotor was either its modern descendant or derived from the same source) in such names as Zarathushtra (Avestan) and ushtra-asana (Sanskrit). It has no further etymology beyond camel, and so was probably from some extinct local non-IE language..
|
|
Rava
Pretorian
Joined: 03-Aug-2004
Location: Poland
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 166
|
Quote Reply
Posted: 01-Nov-2004 at 11:08 |
In Polish camel has no name but is described by its function and abilities. Its typical for hunting societies. We say wielbd [czech. velbloud] what might be translated as: good for vast areas. Wiele = full, whole, a lot of, much and verb bdzi means blunder, err. The only one small desert /sandy/ place in Poland is named using bd- root, therefore in old Polish this word was probably used to name a desert place as well. Where our ancestors have learned camels' abilities it's another question...
|
|
Guests
Guest
|
Quote Reply
Posted: 01-Nov-2004 at 11:37 |
Probably borrowed. The more ancient Avestan (Eastern Iranian) and Sanskrit (Indo-Aryan) word for camel was ushtra (of which shotor was either its modern descendant or derived from the same source) in such names as Zarathushtra (Avestan) and ushtra-asana (Sanskrit). It has no further etymology beyond camel, and so was probably from some extinct local non-IE language.. |
ustra = oshtor = shotor = camel
http://www.geocities.com/Athens/5646/splendor1.html
If that's correct, there is a valid IE substitute for the semitic word Camel!
Edited by Elteber
|
|
Degredado
Consul
Joined: 07-Aug-2004
Location: Portugal
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 366
|
Quote Reply
Posted: 01-Nov-2004 at 12:04 |
Algebra, from the Arab word meaning "teenage stupor".
|
Vou votar nas putas. Estou farto de votar nos filhos delas
|
|
Cyrus Shahmiri
Administrator
King of Kings
Joined: 07-Aug-2004
Location: Iran
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 6240
|
Quote Reply
Posted: 01-Nov-2004 at 12:30 |
Are there any rhinoceros [from Greek "rhinokeras" (rhin=nose & keras=horn)] or crocodile [from Greek "krokodilos"='worm of the stones'] in England?
|
|
|
Sharrukin
Chieftain
Joined: 04-Aug-2004
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 1314
|
Quote Reply
Posted: 02-Nov-2004 at 06:53 |
If that's correct, there is a valid IE substitute for the semitic word Camel! |
Again, the Iranian word for 'camel' is probably from a non-IE source, just as the English word is, ultimately, of non-IE (Semitic) origin. The best that can be said of the earliest known word "ushtra" is that it is a valid Indo-Iranian substitute for the Semitic word 'camel'. Remember, Indo-Iranian is only one branch in the many branches of IE. It was not the "first" or "near the first" group of IE languages. In terms of archaic features, that honor goes to Anatolian and Tocharian.
|
|