Ancient sky map or fake? German experts row over star disc
Luke Harding in Berlin
Tuesday March 1, 2005
The Guardian
One
of Germany's most acclaimed archaeological finds - a 3,600-year-old
disc depicting the stars and the planets - is at the centre of a
dispute following claims that it is a modern forgery.
According to
Germany's museum establishment, the Sky Disc of Nebra is the oldest
depiction of the heavens discovered and offers an insight into the
Bronze Age mind.
But the authenticity
of the disc has been challenged by one of the country's leading
archaeologists, Peter Schauer of Regensburg University. He told a court
in Halle that the artefact was nothing more than an amateurish forgery.
Prof Schauer said that
the ancient-looking green patina on the artefact was not old at all,
and had probably been artificially created in a workshop using acid,
urine and a blowtorch.
The indentations on the disc's side, meanwhile, were also not made by a Bronze Age tool but were done by machine, he said.
"My colleagues don't
want to believe it. But there is little doubt that the disc is a fake,"
he told the Guardian yesterday. "It looks very nice. It has the sky and
the stars. You can even see the Pleiades. But I'm afraid it's a piece
of fantasy."
The disc was allegedly
found in 1999 by two amateur metal detectors. They claimed that they
discovered it in a muddy field close to a prehistoric hill fort near
the east German town of Nebra, with two ancient swords and jewellery.
The amateur archaeol ogists then attempted to sell the disc to various
German museums for 1m marks. Police in the Swiss city of Basel
eventually arrested the pair and they were convicted of handling stolen
goods. They are appealing against the sentence, arguing that if the
disk is a fake they should not have been convicted in the first place.
Last
week a judge in Halle called Prof Schauer as an ex pert witness after
he wrote a letter to the Frankfurter Allgemeine newspaper last November
saying that the disc was a fake.
Other experts, though,
have poured scorn on the professor's testimony. "An examination of the
patina confirms its ancient origins _ I have no doubt that it does
indeed come from the Bronze Age," another professor, Josef Riederer,
told the court. Tests revealed that the disc had come from the Nebra
site, yet another expert, Gregor Borg, claimed.
The case is
embarrassing Germany's curatorial establishment, which had hailed the
disc as the most sensational archaeological discovery of the last
century. The disc, with its gold appliqués, was the oldest concrete
representation of the cosmos to date and a key find not only for
archaeology but also for astronomy and the history of religion, experts
claimed.
It probably belonged
to an early Bronze Age prince, they added, who would have exchanged
goods across Europe. Thousands of Germans have flocked to an exhibition
in Halle to see the disc.
Yesterday, however,
Prof Schauer said the disc could have been manufactured by shamans from
Siberia, and was probably no more than "two or three hundred years
old". Asked whether he might be wrong, he replied: "I spent 19 years
examining finds from across the ancient and Roman world. I know what
I'm talking about."
The judge is likely to rule on the case next week.
LINK