Notice: This is the official website of the All Empires History Community (Reg. 10 Feb 2002)

  FAQ FAQ  Forum Search   Register Register  Login Login

Early history of Bosnia untill 1463 by V

 Post Reply Post Reply Page  12>
Author
violentjack View Drop Down
Earl
Earl
Avatar

Joined: 10-May-2006
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 269
  Quote violentjack Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Topic: Early history of Bosnia untill 1463 by V
    Posted: 10-May-2006 at 13:56
State of Bosnia as a state has its roots in medieval time,probably after colapse of great Bulgarian kingdom under Samuel 893-927 and Croat that started to decline after Tomislav death in around 930,all the way to the death of last Croat king Petar Svacic on Petrova Gora in 1097.In 1102 and Paxa conventa,some Croat historian or theologian would say was joint partnership,and some like late Nada Klaic would say it was occupation of Croatian land,a new state would arise.Name of this state was to be called Bosnia.First written statement comes under Pop Dukljanin memories,Duklja was older state next to Bosnia,today Montenegro,where he is giving his description about its people Bosnjanin and their small state called Terra Bosna,or zemljica Bosna.Bosnia as a state was first mentioned in 1137 by then Hungarian lords of Bella dinasty which will rule Hungary through 1200 period and beyond.In its letter Bella is propoising a servant of Bosnia who will rule the country,under autonomous rule of Hungary,which was at this time,rules of most Balkans.
1137 is first important document that put Bosnia on map of indepent countries,that one ruler wanted to conquer.Few years after this mention around year 1141,powerfull and noble lord from Slavonie(Slavonia) Banus(Ban( Boric,title of avararian roots,usually meant to proclaim ruler under then powerfull Croatian kingdom emerged.He ruled 20 years though his rule was constantly being threatened by Bosnian serfs and some of elites that were opposed that foreigner and non Bosnian,like Boric was be  ruler of small but semi-independent country of Bosnia.In 1163 first attempt of taking crown and leadership from Boric was pushed by then young and later will be most famous Bosnian of all time Kulin to take the throne.Kulin Ban epic figure rose amongst discontent of Bosnian nobles and shame which Boric gave to serfs,nobles and how he runned Bosnian economy.At that time young Kulin from dynasty of Kotromanic,some will say their were goths and were first called Gothoromans,Joh Fine,while Serbs claim he was from Prijezda dynasty,meaning those who ventured away,prijezditi,as Prijezda was first Bosnian ruled before Boric.Anyways by 1180 Kulin managed to take controll of Bosnia and he started to develop his kingdom,without interference of Hungary,that strongly resented this decision,as they were the one,who actually put puppet ruller of Bosnia 30 years before..Kulin ban rule  strenghten Bosnian pride,and increased economy,as he brought Sasen miners,from Sas region,Germans to mine his shafts,and this is the times where literacy was introduced,economy grew and status of Bosnia,as literary center,along with powerfull army grew.Trade was also one of main fact of Kulin rulers,and his famous declaration with Dubrovacani,or Povelja Kulina Bana from 1189 is most famous Bosnian document,that is currently being held in Moscow,but soon will hopefully return to BosniaOld Bosniann saying goes ''od Kulina dana do dobrijeh dana''meaning country was in strong state at that time.By 1199 pressure of pope Innocentio Iv  to convert Kulin,as roman popes considered him heretic will forever brand Bosnia as paghan country,regardless of centuries that will pass.In 1203 and his famous sabour of Bilino,or todays Bilino Polje(Zenica),Kulin was forced to accept missionaries that will enter his kingdom and accept Catholic faith.At this time ill and unhealthy Kulin signed this just because Roman pope,promised economic benefits from this,and because Kulin at deathbed was scared pope might get mad and ally with HUngary,which they will do much often and later in history.Sabor at Bilino Polje,was first attempt to Crush independent Bosnian church and paghans was a whole and to introduce their version of Christianity upon Bosnians.Next year old Kulin dies (1204) and Bosnia becomes gripped with mini civl war,between Kulin son and other nobles who werent satisfied with their choice or rulers.

Next Chapter Bosnia between 1200-1300 impact and politics in Bosnian state
Bosnjaci,probudite se ili nestanite
Back to Top
violentjack View Drop Down
Earl
Earl
Avatar

Joined: 10-May-2006
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 269
  Quote violentjack Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 10-May-2006 at 14:20
Ok,where was i,if anybody has any question about Bosnia untill year 1200,can easily ask me what do they dont know as of yet,as i tried to be detailed,but some minor saying i forgot,but this is just begining of country that will later be most powerfull in Balkans.Period of 1100-1200 is period of virtual occupation and then greater self determination of Bosnia under old but good king Kulin,my best bud

Bosnia from 1200-1300! Chapter 2

First years of Bosnia in 13 century were gripped by civil war and hatred that will develop over time with Roman rules and especially popes.Innocentious Iv ir Innocent IV was first of many Roman popes which was later to be despised by Bosnians,and their leaders of independent Bosnian church.1204 Old Kulin Dies and state is in shock.Leader that brought Bosnian wealth,fame,literacy and trading status,leader that served state for 40 years was gone,and Bosnia was again to be put into status of small state or would be greater state.Period from 1204 to 1232 is gripped by succesion and incompetenet rulers,where kings,nobles and all tried to make them self known.Kulin son took the throne,Hungarian influence increased and Bosnia was still being vasal of more powerfull neighbour to the north,which is Hungary.By year 1232-1251 new strong Bosnian emerges,roothless and he was the man not to be tempered upon.Born Matej(Matija) Ninoslav relative of old Kulin he was man that tried to take over where old Kulin left,but was being heavily influenced by emerging Serbia to the east, Dragutin Uros 1243-1271 and Hungary Arpad dynasty,not to mention semi autonomous Croatia nobles that wanted Bosnia,but i will explain that bit later, in this century.By threaty of Bilino Polje ratified in 1203,Matej was first leader of Bosnian church,later catholic,lather boghumil,as Bosnian kings of the day exchanged religion like dirty socks to introduce foreign missionaries into Bosnia..1244 was the year first Christian missionary order came into Bosnia .Dominikans(Dominikanci) ultra religious zealous preachers who were much conservative then Franciscans who will only later come into Bosnia,but i will say something about them.Uros was still being pain in the neck,all untill his death in 1271,and Bosnia was defending themself against great Serbia,which included then Zahumlje,todays Hercegovina and Croatia under Frankopans,Nelipc,Subics and other nobles that wanted Bosnian for themself.In 1251 Matej Ninoslav dies and Bosnia is still being in mini civil war,which will only end when new powerfull ruler emerges.1291 was the year when first Franciscas or Franjevci came into Bosnia,and they spread christianity at better rate then Dominikans,who camr into Bosnia,some 50 years earlier.Quarel and disatisfaction of new ruler were to be used by then Croat nobles of Subic,or Subici Bribinjski strip of land they gained from Hungary in 1230's that later stretched all the way towards Bosnia and Dubrovnik.Subici Bribinski or Bribinski Subici,took throne of Bosnian in 1298 and untill 1318 they were rulers of Bosnia,.First Mladen and then Pavao Subic tried to conquer Bosnian church,impose catholicism,as they were both very catholic from seacoast,todays region is called Dalmatia.Neither Mladen or Pavao Subic managed to convert people ,though some people  were converted by new and popular Franciscan movement,which will spread only through later years.Subic's were Vojvodas and their amblem or family coat of arms were doubled-headed eagles looking across each other,familiar coat of arms on many rulers during that period.In 1318 but as early as 1315 a new ruler will increase and change Bosnia countryy,economy and status in its Neighborhood

Bosnia from 1315-1401 Chapter 3 next
Bosnjaci,probudite se ili nestanite
Back to Top
violentjack View Drop Down
Earl
Earl
Avatar

Joined: 10-May-2006
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 269
  Quote violentjack Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 10-May-2006 at 14:40
Ok,bad old Subici Bribinjski,who later took last name Zrinjski,but this is more of Croatian history and not Bosnian,were finally defeated militarily by a new and determined leader from family of Kotromanic.This was a new emerging strong leader that will lead Bosnian into 14 century and whose nephew will only increase borders of Bosnia later to come.Stjepan Kotromanic succesfully kicked ass of Subic both Mladen and Pavao and were later exiled into their domains.Sorry for being rude,but their asses were kicked,

Stjepan Kotromanic was leader that united Bosnian nobles,leader that expanded  Bosnian borders to east and west and leader that knew how to deal with Papal states,.Hungary,Serbia and Croatia,and not to mention all those nobles that might oppose him.He regulated equal rights for Serfs,and was even beloved by many other nobles,that somehow didnt get along with Bosnian rulers.From Zlatonosovic,Pavlovic,Altomanovic,Kopcic,Kacic and other nobles he gained respect and left them to rule their domains with knowledge he was a king.By 1325 he is taking land to the east from Stefan Deanski leader of Serbia who was to ruled from 1321-1330,that was succesor of Milutin 1281-1321.He took from Decanski and later from Stefan Dusan 4,or just Tzar Dusan 1331-1355 king of Serbia,area of Zahumlje,majority part,which is todays Hercegovina and parts of Lim region,or Polimlje,region in Eastern Bosnia.Pavlovic lords took Praca at this time from Serbia and increased their border where it stands todays with Serbia by 1320;s near Visegrad.On west he crushed Ivan Nelipac as he took Zavrsje and Donje Kraje from him and increased Bosnian borders tremendously.Those parts are Livno,Glamoc,Duvno and Grahovo,for those who dont know! Stjepan army was great but not the best,but later  will emerge as superpower in Balkans.Stjepan faced Dusan army in winter campaign of 1350-1351 when Dusan crossed into Bosnia just to crash and anex Bosnia.There is old saying in land of heretics,when Ban Zlatonosovic is going to Stjepan Court during that winter saying:

A cestiti kralju,Dusanova vojska je presla Drinu i sa 50 000 ljudi marsira, i vec je stigla do Srebrenika.Sta cemo sa takvom vojskom,cestiti vladaru.Neka Zlatonosovicu,kada Dusan hoce na bracu kristijane da udari,nek zna probudit ce se Bosanski seljak,svak ce stati uz svoju zemlju i vladar i seljak, nek zna Dusan da Bosna je druga zemlja,da nece moci nista Bosnjanu koji se bori za slobodu

Translation is let Dusan knows he wont conquer Bosnia as he conquered many other countries,He crossed river Drina in Winter 1350 with 50 000 soldiers,greatest army ever to be send against Bosnia,and Ban Zlatonosovic is asking Stjepan what should they do next?Stjepan is answering,trust me even serfs will rebell ,fight woman and children,Bosnian spirit will wake up.On plains of Srebrenik Dusan received first defeat in his life,as he was the one that crashed Byzantines and increased Serbia border all the way to Sallonica.That year Bosnians met Dusan again in 1351 this time in Bobovac old castle and town,once capital of Bosnian kingdoms,hardest fort in Bosnian kingdom,where he suffered another defeat.Old Stjepan will die same in -1353 and at this place a new Bosnian will come.He is without a doubt most famous Bosnian of all the time.

Bosnia from 1353-1391 Rise to Superpower and emergence of greatest leader Bosnia had!


Bosnjaci,probudite se ili nestanite
Back to Top
violentjack View Drop Down
Earl
Earl
Avatar

Joined: 10-May-2006
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 269
  Quote violentjack Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 10-May-2006 at 15:03
Ok,part four for those who wanna learn something about Bosnian history,which isnt written by Serb Vuk Karadzic,lol.Man who wrote Serbian history with Gusle,lol

Bosnia from 1353-1391 a golden age of Bosnia!

Period untill 1463 i might not mention,its long ,filled with troubles,killings,selling lands,like Ostoja 1404 land selling to Dubrovcani  and other rulers not to mention Stjepan Tomas,who tried forecully to convert Bosnian,before he was executed by Turks in 1463

Ok,new guy who come into power,person who will change even greater accomplishment of his uncle Stjepan was his nephew Tvrtko. Kotromanic.Aged 17 he inherited great and powerfull Bosnian army that   uncle left him,but also he had to prove himself worthy of his actions.What was his first step?
To increase Bosnian borders.After Dusan death 1355  Serbia is losing lands left and right from Kantakuzemos-Paleogoly Byzantines,Bosnians just increased and took rest of Zahumlje from Him and took parts of coasts.In 1382 he established Bosnian port of Herceg Novi and his fleet of ships numbered more then 500.At that time before 1404 and when King Ostoja sold most of Bosnian seacoast to Mletani or Dubrovcani,Bosnian had more then 750 km of seacost.In the west he faced Subic bitter losers who received another loss,he crushed Nelipac and took even more land ,region of Donji Kraji,todays Krajina region and took Kozara,Pset and many other towns.,In 1366 jealous and angry Ladislau Hungarian ruler,crossed into Bosnia and started to defeat Bosnian in some squirmishes.In 1366 he was to meet Bosnian Tvrtko on battle field near todays Sarajevo,where Ladislau had to pack their soldiers,while Tvrtko kick the hell out of them back into Hungary.Go  back to Hungary were chants of Bosnians,while they kicked their ass.Ladislau bitter and defeated wrote to pope that Bosnians are all to one kanibals,that they eat horse bloood,and all were supported by Serbian rulers,who were still bitter after defeats they suffered and rulers they lost.In 1371 Serbs contingnent by Vukan man who wrote to Pope that Bosnians are uber heretics drowned in Maritza river,as Serbs lost first out of many battles with new supowerpower from the east=Ottoman Turks.By 1376 Bosnian Ban Tvrtko state was well over 100 000km2,has merchants ships that went into Venice,and was strongest Balkan country at that time.Bulgaria was shadow state that was once been under Samuel or Khan Khrum and Michaeh Shishmen,Bulgarian leader didnt accomplish much,only complete defeat which will later com.By 1376-1377 some will dispute sabor and  some wont at Mileseva(Prijepolje) Polimlje region King Tvrtko proclaimed himself as vladar(Ruler) Dalmacije,Bosne,Srbije and Polimlja,on ground that his grandma was a Serb,.His grandma was Jelena Grubor,daughter of Stefan Dusan 4,Tzar of Serbia who died in 1355 aged 47.Maniac that wrote Dusanov Zakonik and lost against Bosnians.So by 1389 when Serbia faith was doomed,and not a game DOOM<by battle of Kosovo,Bosnian send contingent of Soldiers to help Serbs,led by Nadvojvoda Vlatko Vukovic with some 500-1000 Cavalryman and 1000 infantry man .Serbs lost the battle and they bitch ever since.Tvrtko will die soon and Bosnia will have less then 100 years as sovereign state.Then came his son who was minor,then,so his rule was given to Ostoja,noble whole rules from 1398-1404 and 1408-1412.Ostoja was gambler and drunk and he spend money and sold our country especially our coast to Dubrovcani and Mletani,before gying some 20 years later at Zgosce near Kakanj.


Bosnjaci,probudite se ili nestanite
Back to Top
violentjack View Drop Down
Earl
Earl
Avatar

Joined: 10-May-2006
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 269
  Quote violentjack Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 10-May-2006 at 15:05
Ok, i have bit headache from all the writing i did here.If here anybody has any question about pre-Ottoman Bosnia 1463 period or Herzegovina 1482 is welcome to ask me.Im bit tired from all those essays so il sleep a bit 
Bosnjaci,probudite se ili nestanite
Back to Top
Mila View Drop Down
Tsar
Tsar
Avatar
Retired AE Moderator

Joined: 17-Sep-2005
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 4030
  Quote Mila Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 10-May-2006 at 16:35
Great work, Violentjack. It's nice to have someone else here with the same perspective.
[IMG]http://img272.imageshack.us/img272/9259/1xw2.jpg">
Back to Top
osmi View Drop Down
Immortal Guard
Immortal Guard
Avatar

Joined: 05-Aug-2006
Location: Bosnia Hercegovina
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 0
  Quote osmi Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 05-Aug-2006 at 07:14
God piece of work Jack. Congratulations to your patience to write this much!
Back to Top
The Hidden Face View Drop Down
Chieftain
Chieftain
Avatar
Ustad-i Azam

Joined: 16-Jul-2005
Location: Mexico
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 1379
  Quote The Hidden Face Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 05-Aug-2006 at 07:41
Amazing job, indeed.
Back to Top
Leonardo View Drop Down
General
General
Avatar

Joined: 13-Jan-2006
Location: Italy
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 778
  Quote Leonardo Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 07-Aug-2006 at 05:40
Interesting infos ... Only I wonder why this post is in Post-classical Middle East Confused
Back to Top
Leonardo View Drop Down
General
General
Avatar

Joined: 13-Jan-2006
Location: Italy
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 778
  Quote Leonardo Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 09-Aug-2006 at 12:21
Ok, now it is in the right place Smile
Back to Top
BoFF View Drop Down
Immortal Guard
Immortal Guard
Avatar

Joined: 17-Aug-2006
Location: Bosnia Hercegovina
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 0
  Quote BoFF Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 17-Aug-2006 at 20:24

 

Some nice work, but quite a few of your historical facts are wrong.

Quote:
First written statement comes under Pop Dukljanin memories,Duklja was older state next to Bosnia,today Montenegro,where he is giving his description about its people Bosnjanin and their small state called Terra Bosna,or zemljica Bosna.
 
Fact:
The first written mention of Bosnia (as ''ton horion Bosona''), is from the writings of Byzantine emperor Constantine VII Porphyrogenitus, in the middle of the 10th century.
 
Quote:
Prijezda was first Bosnian ruled before Boric.
 
Fact:
Ban Boric is the first ban of Bosnia that we know by his name.
 
Quote:
Sabor at Bilino Polje,was first attempt to Crush independent Bosnian church and paghans was a whole and to introduce their version of Christianity upon Bosnians.
 
Fact:
There was no independent Bosnian church on the council (sabor, as you would have it) of Bilino Polje. Infact, there is no such institution before the middle of the 13th century, when the dislocation of the bosnian bishopry to the Slavonian town of Djakovo happened.
 
Quote:
jealous and angry Ladislau Hungarian ruler.
 
Fact:
The kings name was Lois, or Lajo, or Ludovic, the Great, not Ladislau.
 
Quote:
By 1376-1377 some will dispute sabor and  some wont at Mileseva(Prijepolje) Polimlje region King Tvrtko proclaimed himself as vladar(Ruler) Dalmacije,Bosne,Srbije and Polimlja,on ground that his grandma was a Serb.
 
Fact:
King Tvrtkos coronation took place in 1377 in the church of st. Nicholas in a place then called Mili. Today that place is known as Arnautovici, and lies not far from where fictional archeologists are trying to dig out a fictional pyramid.
 
 
If you want more information, just ask me.
 
Pozdrav!
Back to Top
violentjack View Drop Down
Earl
Earl
Avatar

Joined: 10-May-2006
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 269
  Quote violentjack Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 22-Aug-2006 at 07:41
Sorry, i made this short.but let me correct your mistakes and not mine.I could have said it more, or more about Bosnian church, but i wanted this to be more concize and shorter, i missed some period, i knew that, but hey, im not perfect!

Let me now, just correct your mistakes

1)Tera Bosnia or zemljica Bosnia, is mentioned in chronicle of Pop Dukljanin, but it has its flaws like Ajndahrt, Jordanes(1 century historian) or any other historian of that time.Meaning they cant be for certain, it reminds me of book travelers by Evlija Celebija, some details are very correct, but some are lot of fascination in work.Thats pop dukljanin for you


2)Bosnia was mentioneed in 919, before battle of Bosnia 926(Someplace from Vrhbosna and Rama)

Combantants were Tomislav king of Croatia and Simeun Bulgarian King 893-927

Prijezda was noble from dinasty Kotromanic, and he wasnt first official ruler of Bosnia at that time.Prijezda in slavic means, prijezditi or go across water.This is well known fact to me, but first real leader was Boric, though his ruling was unpopular one.


Sabor of Bilino 1203  was act of loyalty that Innocentious(Innocent) 3 asked from Bosnian king Kulin,that he formally adopts catholic faith.After 1054 and Claremont, churches were pretty much divided.Again, i didnt mention that, as i said, but ok.Got me, and i knew that ages ago

Halecki is mentioining Ladislau
And those are derivations of same name, which means i was right

At that time ruler or Serbia was Vukan regent who would die in Maritza battle 1371.Decisive battle occured in 1366, where Hungarian king Ladislau, was defeated by smaller Bosnian force.

Tvrtko coronation is disputed.Some like you are mentioning Mile, some are mentioning Dalmatia, and most historian go towards Mileseva near Prijepolje.We wil never know this part.


And yes if you wanna know more of Bosnian history, you just ask me

Thanks


Bosnjaci,probudite se ili nestanite
Back to Top
violentjack View Drop Down
Earl
Earl
Avatar

Joined: 10-May-2006
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 269
  Quote violentjack Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 22-Aug-2006 at 07:46
By the way i know place is called Arnautovici.There is one big stone, near by it says kings stone, so this is location of kings burial, which one, i wouldnt know?

Ostoja was burried in Zgosce near Kakanj?
Tomas in Jajce?
I believe this had to be burial crypt of old Bosnian kings(Mid 11-13 century.Rulers mainly expanded across Bosnia in mid 14 century , after Subics were kicked out in 1318, and after Kotromanic gained power in 1318

.


Bosnjaci,probudite se ili nestanite
Back to Top
violentjack View Drop Down
Earl
Earl
Avatar

Joined: 10-May-2006
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 269
  Quote violentjack Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 22-Aug-2006 at 07:53
Again i know a lot, but im not perfect
I didnt add up some few details, which was my bad

Establishment of Bosnian towns from Gorazde 1374,Olovo 1332
I didnt add up about economy in Bosnia from 1318 towards 1391.I didnt add up some things like Bosnian bans, from Sankovici,Kopcici,Hranici,Pavlovici Ivanis, and many more nobles.I could have said some more about Bosnian church.I could have said something about Stecak, my bad again

I could have said something about Arnautovici, but then againl, if i would mention all in one time, people would think im somekind of robot?

No, i made few crucial mistakes, so did Pop Dukljanin and so did Ajndhart with his Krka  comments, so did Celebija.Chronicles of priest Dukljanin are nice part, but i dont think, no insult Duclea knew much about Bosnia, not untill midd 12 century.

Ladislau is same derivation, Lajos, would be Hungarian, or Louis,



But if you have specific time period, you can ask me some
Smile
Bosnjaci,probudite se ili nestanite
Back to Top
NikeBG View Drop Down
Colonel
Colonel


Joined: 04-Jan-2006
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 529
  Quote NikeBG Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 22-Aug-2006 at 08:41
Originally posted by violentjack

Combantants were Tomislav king of Croatia and Simeun Bulgarian King 893-927

Phew, you finally nearly learned his right name! In all your previous mentionings about the Battle of the Bosnian Highlands, you were replacing Simeon with Samuil... LOL
Back to Top
violentjack View Drop Down
Earl
Earl
Avatar

Joined: 10-May-2006
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 269
  Quote violentjack Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 22-Aug-2006 at 08:53
Big smileWell slight mistake
I alaways said Tzar Simeon
Simiun
Dont think i called him SamuilSmile
Bosnjaci,probudite se ili nestanite
Back to Top
BoFF View Drop Down
Immortal Guard
Immortal Guard
Avatar

Joined: 17-Aug-2006
Location: Bosnia Hercegovina
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 0
  Quote BoFF Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 22-Aug-2006 at 20:06

Lets be open about this; i corrected you, you don't have to correct my corrections.

1) Pop Dukljanin mentions Bosnia, but it is not the first written document it is mentioned in. The first is the De Administrando Imperio. Every schoolboy knows that.

2) Once again, there is no WRITTEN mention of Bosnia before the middle of the 10th century; the fact that the Battle took place on the territory of modern Bosnia, does not mean that it was mentioned then. It is not even certain that it took place on bosnian political soil. By the way, could you, just for reference sake, tell me which author speaks of Bosnia in 919?

3) Ok, you were wrong about Prijezda. He was not the first ruler of Bosnia. Prijezda is the name of two (or three) bosnian bans in the second half of the 13th century. It is not known if they were memebers of the Kotromanic family.

4) I was not saying that the council in Bilino polje (or Bolino poilo, as the sources would have it), never took place. I said that no independent Church of Bosnia existed at that time. This is another thing that every schoolboy knows.

5) I think that Halecki could not have made such a mistake. Ladislav cannot be a deviation of the name Loius (Lajo, Ludovic, Luis, Ludvig...), Ladislav and Louis are names in their own right. King Ladislav of Naples was certainly not the same historical figure as King Loius of Hungary. Maybe the translator is to blame.

6) The Tvrtko coronation is the most blatant example of serbian toying with Bosnian history. No contemporary written records exist that he was crowned in Mileseva at the grave of Saint Sava; only in the writings of Mauro Orbini (Il Regno degli Sclavi, Pesaro, 1601.), can you find that information. It is obvious that Orbini mentions the coronation of the king in Milesevo, but a few pages earlier he says that ban Stjepan II was buried in Milesevo - if we know that ban Stjepan was buried in Mile (other sources testify this), and that Mile are sometimes called Milesevo, and that all the other Bosnian kings had their crowning ceremonies in Mile (except the last one) - we cannot dispute it - the coronation of king Tvrtko took place in Mili, today called Arnautovići. The Dalmatia thing is out of the question - no-one mentions it.

7) I will not ask YOU ANYTHING from Bosnian history, becouse I simply know more than you. And I'm not joking.

The second post:

1) In Arnautovici, Mile of old days, you can find the foundations of the church of st. Nicholas, and the grave of ban Stjepan II, and of king Tvrtko I. No more bosnian rulers were buried in Mile. King Ostoja was buried in the church of st. Michael in Bobovac, as was his brother King Tvrtko II, and Stjepan Toma. King Stjepan Tomaević was buried in Jajce. His grave was dug out a long time ago and his body rests in the local franciscan monastery. No Bosnian ruler was buried in Zgosca. Older writers thought that the big stecak from Zgosca had to be a kings or bans gravestone, but as we know, nothing confirms their thesis. Especially if the ornaments and decorations of the stone seem to be of a later date, and we know the burial places of later rulers.

third post

I know you can't say everything on the subject in a few short sentences. But try to make as fewer mistakes as possible in the things that you do say. Ok? And please try not to act as if you know so much. I do not need to ask YOU questions about specific time periods, becouse you'll probably make more mistakes. Example, try to tell me something about Pribislav Vukotic and Restoje Milohna. If you do, I will consider you more adequate to give people lessons from Bosnian medieval history, than I am.

Ok?

Back to Top
violentjack View Drop Down
Earl
Earl
Avatar

Joined: 10-May-2006
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 269
  Quote violentjack Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 22-Aug-2006 at 22:06
1) Most historian dont mention DEI as valid historical point in researching.Bosnia was first mentioned in 8 century, way before Dei

2)Same as 1 answer

3)Me, wrong about Prijezda.I think i know something.He is founding father of Kotromanic dynasty.That was his nick Prijezda.In middle ages Prijezdite meant went across the river, thats why Prijezda.He wasnt first official ruler, that was Boric.

4)I know more about Bilino sabor, then you, so dont get your hope high, instead asking, you do acccusation part

5)Derivation of same name, i didnt mention German king Otto , mentioned same person, and same historical things which happened.If on other hand i said king was called Angelo, then you would have valid point

6)Orbinni is adventurer and his historical perspective is not really influenced by any historian.I Never said anything about Mileseva, there is no valid evidence, to swing it both ways.

7)Sure you do, sure you ''do''

8)King Ostoja was burried in Donja Zgosca near Kakanj,now just Zgosca.Go, visit village, you still have kings tomb there.Such historian

9)If i dont know about Pribislav Vukotnic and  Restoje Milohna.There were some 300 lords, if not more, all ruled specific area of Bosnia in middle ages?Me, knowing every single lord, is hard task for anybody

Zlatonosovici-Srebrenik
Kopcic-Uskoplje(Bugojno-Donji Vakuf)
Sankovic -Konjic-Kalinovik
Pavlovic(Praca,Pale,Gorazde,Vrhbosna)
Altomanovici (Tuzla)
Vukcic(Jajce)
Kosaca(Kljuc,Blagaj later)
Kacic(Uskoplje)
Radivojevic(Stolac)
Nelipac(Bosnian dynasty) Originally Croat nobles from Trilj,Zagvozd,Livno
Want some more?

No, guess i cant memorize all Bosnian nobles now, can i?
Should i memorize every single last name now?
Guess my bad?
What do you know about Ivan Izacic?
About Jurica  and Kristof Hranilovic
Marko Mesic,Vuk Mandusic,Stojan Jankovic
What do you know about big plague in Herzegovina?


Since you ask me minor things, against a guy, that knows my family tree for hundreds of years,

Village Krizevac that used to exist,changed name during Ottoman rule, whats the name of village today?
Just answer me that question, and i will admit you are brilliant historian, and know middle age Bosnia,better then me

Here, since you like replies, and i see, you really jumped into conclusion

What were decisions of Bilino Sabor, main ones?
Name me three big steps taken there?

Here is one easy question?
Pusestvije was written by which Serbian noble and ruler?


If you answer my question in range of 80-100% i will bow down, and call you better historian then me, not only that, i will call you king amongst man.No, insult taken, im just testing your vast knowledge, you are bound to have.

Name me two Muslim families leading Krajina bey families, and where did they come from?
What was principle of Gabela trEaty between Mletani and Bosnia, when Bosnians gained Gabela?

Svistov peace 1791 gave what town to Croatia, and why was it important?



Since you are so smart, and since you think you know something, let me ask you few questions?


Here, no disrespect towards you, i always like to learn history, since you can never learn enough of that.

Asked you 11 Questions?
You get 7 right, il say you are good historian, and you have my respect

If you get 9 right, il say you know better then me?

If you get all right, then i will bow down, because your knowledge is really-really vast

My apology, i will hopefully get your answers?

Again, no disrespect, but since you do mention non-valid sources like Dei and Dukljanin, i gave you few real historical questions, everybody can deny Dei, even 9 year old would be historian

Read slow questions i asked, and then think about answer and time?

Thanks, again no insultWink

Have fun if you dare, answering my questions?Smile




Bosnjaci,probudite se ili nestanite
Back to Top
violentjack View Drop Down
Earl
Earl
Avatar

Joined: 10-May-2006
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 269
  Quote violentjack Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 22-Aug-2006 at 22:19
Ok, its Soli, not Tuzla, but i worked myself into present day

Altomanovici(Soli)

Just wanna play like it was, at that time.



Ps:When i say to somebody loud, he knows more Bosnian history then me, is compliment.As i have read everything regarding this period, regardless who was author.I will hope you dont get insulted now, and start answering my questions

Here is how we play

11-3 you know something
11-7 you know a lot, but not better then me
11-9 i will admit you know history better then me (Bosnian)
11-11 My respect is there, if you answer every single question, and i will gladly say you know Bosnian history better then me.Some off those questions cant be found on Wikipedia, only in few selected books, that is


Bosnjaci,probudite se ili nestanite
Back to Top
NikeBG View Drop Down
Colonel
Colonel


Joined: 04-Jan-2006
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 529
  Quote NikeBG Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 23-Aug-2006 at 06:21
Sorry for interrupting your "argue" in here, but I have one side-question: Does anyone have a full English (or at least some Slavic) translation in the Internet of "Letopis Popa Dukljanina"? I found this, but it seems it's only some excerpts...
Back to Top
 Post Reply Post Reply Page  12>

Forum Jump Forum Permissions View Drop Down

Bulletin Board Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 9.56a [Free Express Edition]
Copyright ©2001-2009 Web Wiz

This page was generated in 0.047 seconds.