Print Page | Close Window

what do you think of salamn farsi?

Printed From: History Community ~ All Empires
Category: Regional History or Period History
Forum Name: Post-Classical Middle East
Forum Discription: SW Asia, the Middle East and Islamic civilizations from 600s - 1900 AD
URL: http://www.allempires.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=3844
Printed Date: 20-Apr-2024 at 07:42
Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 9.56a - http://www.webwizforums.com


Topic: what do you think of salamn farsi?
Posted By: kiyumars
Subject: what do you think of salamn farsi?
Date Posted: 07-Jun-2005 at 14:14
what do you think of salman farsi?
at school we were taught that he was on of prophet mohammad's "sahabe" ( can roughly be translated "disciples" ,for non-muslems). We were told he was Iranian and we as Iranians should be proud of him cuz prophet said about him "salmano men ana va ana men salamn" means Salamn is from me and I am from salamn.
However, i read somewhere that when arabs invaded iran at the time of Omar he was arab army's guide. he was the person who led them and actually showed them the way to conquer Madaen.
is that true? If this is true, he is just a dirty traitor who betrayed his land and is not worth the prais. I wonder how arabs could trust someone who betrayed his own people.
what do you think????



Replies:
Posted By: Behrouz
Date Posted: 07-Jun-2005 at 15:00
I have to finish the book I'm reading called 23 years and a bunch of more books to figure out what Salman's role really was. It appears there's even a hadith from prophet's wife that goes something like "what is he saying (mohammad) that he recieves messages from god, I only saw him talk to sandal-less Salman"

If that's true the theory that Salman had big hands in creation of Islam could be true.


Posted By: Behi
Date Posted: 08-Jun-2005 at 04:47

http://ayeen-avesta.blogspot.com/ - http://ayeen-avesta.blogspot.com/

Read " Quran Sorodei be sabke Parsi" book After "23 sal"
Disappintedly my Link dosen't exist anymore.
if any one have link, put at farsi ebook artickle

In my Openion he was big traitor, who had lead enemy to his mother land



-------------


Posted By: ramin
Date Posted: 08-Jun-2005 at 11:46
Why do you like to bump those who are praised by the Islamic government? Salman (BTW that's the correct spelling) played a significant role in spreading Islam (althought, I wish he hadn't done so). I've never heard of his guidance to Persia, but he did give the idea of building fosses around the Arab army's camp so the Sassanid calvary with elephants wouldn't be able to attack. so, he might've been a traitor, but he also was a free man, looking for spirituality and chose what came close to his heart.

-------------
"I won't laugh if a philosophy halves the moon"


Posted By: magavan
Date Posted: 10-Jun-2005 at 12:45
Salman al farci was a zoroastrian traitor who taught to Mohamad the basis of Islam. Salman al farci created Islam and gave cultures to those savage arabs.


Posted By: kiyumars
Date Posted: 10-Jun-2005 at 13:45
Magavan wrote:
"Salman al farci was a zoroastrian traitor who taught to Mohamad the basis of Islam. Salman al farci created Islam and gave cultures to those savage arabs".

sounds logical. we were told at school that Zoroasterianism is the closest religion to islam in terms of everything.
That could well be the reason.


Posted By: Murtaza
Date Posted: 10-Jun-2005 at 14:00

That nationalism was not common at that times. And even I will put my religion prior to my blood. He did what he think right as just all honorful man.



Posted By: Behi
Date Posted: 11-Jun-2005 at 00:56


Originally posted by ramin

Why do you like to bump those who are praised by the Islamic government? Salman (BTW that's the correct spelling) played a significant role in spreading Islam (althought, I wish he hadn't done so)....

You are aproaching to Politcal sight, Who Bump?
He is Historic person as Rostam Farokhzad but so opposite manners.

Rostam sacrifice himself to Graeat Iran, but salman side ... arabs.

at Religious view: we must proud to him, indeed Islam is indebted to him
but at Patrotic view: He were great traitor to our mother land



-------------


Posted By: ramin
Date Posted: 11-Jun-2005 at 02:34
Originally posted by magavan

Salman al farci was a zoroastrian traitor who taught to Mohamad the basis of Islam. Salman al farci created Islam and gave cultures to those savage arabs.
Magavan, I've got a friendly challenge for you; Can you write a post wihtout using the words "Zoroastrism" and "Vedism"? Salman was a man looking for a new faith. He became a Manichean, a Christian, and then Muslim. I don't think he considered being Muslim is equal to being Arab. Mohammad and his family trusted him, and I know that Arabs didn't like him.

@ Land of Aryan
are we sure that the notion of "Mother land" did actually make sense back then? Is this not a sort of teleological reasoning?

I think the defeat of the Sasanian Army did not mean the defeat of Iranians. I doubt if people had a notion of a "national" government back then. I imagine that for local people, the Sasanians were yet another government, and when they got too tyranical and parasitic, people would not have minded removing them.

I agree that later, when people realised that what they get was Umayyad Caliphs and Hajja ibn Yusef, then they did develop a sort of culture based resistance. And you know Arabs couldn't apply Islam to Iranians, Iranians became Muslims in time of Samanids and Safavids.


-------------
"I won't laugh if a philosophy halves the moon"


Posted By: azimuth
Date Posted: 11-Jun-2005 at 03:20

 

Originally posted by magavan

Salman al farci was a zoroastrian traitor who taught to Mohamad the basis of Islam. Salman al farci created Islam and gave cultures to those savage arabs.

yes sure he was the real mohammed. he also created christanity judaisim and all other religions. everthing came from iran , iran is the world and the world is iran. human are actully iranian and then they became humans.

the good news is that its only you and people like you who r thinking this way without proofs and sources.



Originally posted by ramin

And you know Arabs couldn't apply Islam to Iranians, Iranians became Muslims in time of Samanids and Safavids.

yea when they became shiiees.

and shiees are muslims and others who call them selfs muslims are kafers right?

i wonder untill the samanids iranians were zoroastrain or sunnie kafers?

 

 



-------------


Posted By: ramin
Date Posted: 11-Jun-2005 at 04:39
Why kafir?

Up to the rise of Samanids, Iranian people were not using Arabic names I am sure of that. About the religion I do not know. This is an interesting subject and i will look more into it.


-------------
"I won't laugh if a philosophy halves the moon"


Posted By: ramin
Date Posted: 11-Jun-2005 at 04:54
Originally posted by azimuth

yes sure he was the real mohammed. he also created christanity judaisim and all other religions. everthing came from iran , iran is the world and the world is iran. human are actully iranian and then they became humans.
LoL Azimuth he doesn't think that way but he thinks everything is Indian and comes from the Veda... including Zoroastrism and Iran


-------------
"I won't laugh if a philosophy halves the moon"


Posted By: Behi
Date Posted: 11-Jun-2005 at 05:58

Hey People Azimuth RETURNS!!!!!

& Thanks god , all Humans aren't ARAB, If they were, still grave their girls, still victimize own son to god, still were in desert follow Lizards, still burn books & says we have Quran

Originally posted by azimuth

yes sure he was the real mohammed. he also created christanity judaisim and all other religions. everthing came from iran , iran is the world and the world is iran. human are actully iranian and then they became humans.

Why not????LOL



-------------


Posted By: Murtaza
Date Posted: 11-Jun-2005 at 06:08

Land of Aryan you are realy a lost cause. I didnt ever think iranians are so ultra-nationalist. It is weird you build a islamic country, But you have nothing related with islam. If we accept islams came from Iranians, Should we call iranians also Allah?

 

 



Posted By: Behi
Date Posted: 11-Jun-2005 at 06:31

@Mortaza

We didn't say Islam comes From Iran,

This aricle was about Salman Farsi & his hand in Islam.

Did you have read all Posts???



-------------


Posted By: Murtaza
Date Posted: 11-Jun-2005 at 06:36
magavan wrote:
Salman al farci was a zoroastrian traitor who taught to Mohamad the basis of Islam. Salman al farci created Islam and gave cultures to those savage arabs.

yes sure he was the real mohammed. he also created christanity judaisim and all other religions. everthing came from iran , iran is the world and the world is iran. human are actully iranian and then they became humans.

the good news is that its only you and people like you who r thinking this way without proofs and sources

You read this?

& Thanks god , all Humans aren't ARAB, If they were, still grave their girls, still victimize own son to god, still were in desert follow Lizards, still burn books & says we have Quran

And this one is not nice too. They made their mistakes too. so what? Everyone made mistake. You dont need to attack all race.

I dont think all Iranians are like you, or I hope not. I dont care If you claim saka are iranic, safavids are iranic. or so on so on. But this is too much.



Posted By: magavan
Date Posted: 11-Jun-2005 at 07:14

Originally posted by ramin

Originally posted by magavan

Salman al farci was a zoroastrian traitor who taught to Mohamad the basis of Islam. Salman al farci created Islam and gave cultures to those savage arabs.
Magavan, I've got a friendly challenge for you; Can you write a post wihtout using the words "Zoroastrism" and "Vedism"? Salman was a man looking for a new faith. He became a Manichean, a Christian, and then Muslim. I don't think he considered being Muslim is equal to being Arab. Mohammad and his family trusted him, and I know that Arabs didn't like him.

Ramin you are so ignorant, Vedism created zoroastrism, Zoroastrism created Islam, this is an evidence. We call that evolution...

Salman Al farci grew up in a zoroastrian family. Each monotheist concept is plagia of zoroastrism...



Posted By: magavan
Date Posted: 11-Jun-2005 at 07:21
Originally posted by azimuth

 yes sure he was the real mohammed. he also created christanity judaisim and all other religions. everthing came from iran , iran is the world and the world is iran. human are actully iranian and then they became humans.

the good news is that its only you and people like you who r thinking this way without proofs and sources.

Yes the world mind comes from the aryan religion (zoroastrism and vedism). Proofs: Nietzcheh:" thus spoke zarathustra" and different comparative studies. One day you will understand the power of Iran 



Posted By: Behi
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 04:00

Thank you Magavan

about Salman refer to " Quran Nahl 103 "
name of Salman & Islam & Salam has same orgin come from Sa,La,ma
basic samples for debt of Islam from Iran:

1. 5 pray (namaz) of Muslim is copy from 5 pary of Zartoshtian even in the same times of day

2. " Ashhado ana la elaha ela Allah  v ashhado ana Mohmmad rasol Allah " = " man aghrar daram v ostovaram bedin Mazdisni ke mokhalefe dive parasti ast v Zartosht avarande in kish Ahoraei ast" both with same Translation = " I Confess to God & Zartosht/Mohamad is messenger from God "

3. " Besme Allah alrhman e alrahim " = " be nam Izad bakhshande va mehraban " same traslation too = " in the name of compassionate & Merciful God "

3. Equality of women & men in Iran, cause to save arab girls life who graved by her father, but still woman is 1/2 man in Islam

4. Equality of people, first raised by Mazdak

5. Serat Birdge in Islam = Chinvat bridge in Avesta

6. Mehrabe with(å) was place to Praise of Mitra ,in Islam become Mehrab with(Í) & means " place of war " but still is place for pray!!!!

7. Ghadr nights debted from our Yalda night
...

Christendom debts:
1. Xmas night = Mitra Birthday
2. noel pine = Aryan Cedar
3. Halovin night = Zartoshtian's deads night
...

in most of religions one man will come & eliminate tyranny & will govern with justice
first found at Zarvan openion is Mitra, then in Zartoshtism is Soshiant, in Islam is Mahdi

Resurrection day first come from Zarvan & then Zartosht

Paradise = Pardis ,& hell too

Compare "Cyrus the great behaviour to outsiders & most Important Jews", with Muslims behaviour with outsiders as us, They bayonet us to accept Relagion or leave land or pay ransom.

& more......

refer to " 23 sal " & " Quran Sordehei be sabke Parsi " & "az Mitra ta Mohammad " Books & http://ayeen-avesta.blogspot.com/ - http://ayeen-avesta.blogspot.com/



-------------


Posted By: Murtaza
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 04:09

So we believe in a iranic religion? This is complately a insult to us.

What name did you give your this new ideas? Sun theory? Need help?



Posted By: Behi
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 04:53
 
Originally posted by murtaza

So we believe in a iranic religion? This is complately a insult to us.

What name did you give your this new ideas? Sun theory? Need help?

Every things intended to Iran insult you & Oguzoglu & Kenaney.

Safavid is Insult to you
Saka is Insult to you
Molana is Insult to you
Amazon is Insult to you
Turanian is Insult to you
I am Insult to you
Magevan is Insult to you
anyway name of IRAN is Insult to you

Yes I'm Patriot, & I'll not be quiet about IRAN

Oguzoglu Deny Chaldoran Battle
Kenaney revile us
in the tourism advertiseing at satellite channel, you use our Partia Statue.
what about your glorious Mongol fathers bloodbath at Nishabor, Isfahan, Kerman, Sabzevar,...
These aren't insult to you????? 

Yes, These are Insult to me, but I never offensive you.



-------------


Posted By: Murtaza
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 05:02

Pah, My friend I dont care about history. Past is past. Reality is both of us is poor and pathetic countries.

 But I realy no intent of believing an iranian religion. Infact

You should realy think about sun theory.



Posted By: Cyrus Shahmiri
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 05:28

One night the Persian scribe had a dream in which he was hovering above the figure of Mohammad the Prophet's cave on Mount Cone....[It] struck him that his point of view had been that of the arch-angel, and at that moment the memory of the incident of the Satanic verses came back to him as vividly as if the thing had happened the previous day. "Maybe I hadn't dreamed of myself as Gibreel," Salman recounted. "Maybe I was Shaitan [Satan]." The realization of this possibility gave him his diabolic idea. After that, when he sat at the Prophet's feet, writing down rules rules rules, he began, surreptitiously, to change things.
"Little things at first. If Mohammad recited a verse in which God was described as all-hearing, all-knowing, I would write, all-knowing, all-wise. Here's the point: Mohammad did not notice the alterations. So there I was, actually writing the book, polluting the word of God with my own profane language. But, good heavens, if my poor words could not be distinguished from the Revelation by God's own messenger, then what did that mean? What did that say about the quality of the divine poetry? Look, I swear, I was shaken to my soul....I was writing the Revelation and nobody was noticing, and I didn't have the courage to own up. I was scared silly, I can tell you. Also: I was sadder than I have ever been.
Ahmed Rushdie (Salman)



-------------


Posted By: Murtaza
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 05:53

I think Iranians are more ultranationalist than any race. I have no problem with iranians. But this is realy realy becoming comic. And when they thin Islam came from Iran, It becomes also boring. Do you realy believe Islam? I will not believe a religion which cames from a man.

Ahmed Rushdie (Salman)? will we realy care about what this guy write? I think even Iranians dont like him much. It looks like the Iranian member of this post are not much relation with  iranians. Or all iran think like this?

 



Posted By: magavan
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 07:07

Islam as tokhme Iran miad, Donia as tokhme Iran miad.

Everything in this world come from  arya-vaeja / Arya-varta.

 



Posted By: Cyrus Shahmiri
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 07:51

lol magavan, don't make it "racist"!

Murtaza, "living under an Islamic state" has had a big effect on Iranians, it is a fact that some Iranians really hate Islam and some others try to make it Iranian!



-------------


Posted By: azimuth
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 08:08
Originally posted by magavan

Islam as tokhme Iran miad, Donia as tokhme Iran miad.

Everything in this world come from  arya-vaeja / Arya-varta.

 

yea  whatever

you are like what? a 0.000000000001% in the world who thinks like this so i dont think there is any reason for me to care about what you think.

i wonder how much you hate the french you live in their country. and that you who gave them this "Donya"



-------------


Posted By: Cyrus Shahmiri
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 08:24
Originally posted by magavan

Islam as tokhme Iran miad, Donia as tokhme Iran miad.

Everything in this world come from  arya-vaeja / Arya-varta.

 

Donia doesn't come form Iranian because it is an Arabic word!



-------------


Posted By: Murtaza
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 08:27

I always think Dunya is a  Turkish word

Infact I dont care if they hate islam, Or If they change their religion.

But pls dont change my religion.

 



Posted By: kiyumars
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 08:50
Dear Murtaza,
fortunately (or maybe unfortunately) this is the way 90% of iranians think. islam is dead in iran. what you hear from the media of the islamic government is all fake, absolue sham. I have had some friends from other islamic countries who were studying in Iran and were really shocked at the reality that they saw in Tehran's streets.
too much different from the picture that they had in mind about iran, which had been made by the iranian and western media. if you had lived under the so called islamic regim of iran and had wasted the best years of your life under cruel Mullas who commit all crime in the name of Allah, you would think the same.
so please do not judge them and don't blame them


Posted By: Zagros
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 11:14

Where are you from kiyumars?

My friends gran used to think Mohamad and Ali were Iranian. people who want to be muslim have a right to be as much as people who do not.  What I hate is when people try to impose their religious beliefs or lack thereof on others.



-------------


Posted By: kiyumars
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 15:29
Purya,
i'm not trying to impose anything on anyone.
I just gave some info. on the current state of islam in iran esp. among iranian youth. You most probably have lived all your life in the UK but i have lived all my life in iran. i have been living in austria for only a year. so i think i am at a position to comment about this issue after 30 years of living under the terrifying reign of mullas.
i know living in a free democratic country has made you a
a person who belives in the so called speech freedom and the stuff and you feel shocked at comments like this.
but i'm not a UK educated individual .I'm a mullah reign product. so don't blame me.
If you don't beleive me pay a visit to your mother land and witness. By the way, when was the last time you were in Iran?


Posted By: Murtaza
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 15:41

kiyumars

Do this justify for destroying islam itself(making it Iranic,Iranian or what ever)?

I am not blaming anyone, but noone have right to destroy my religion too.

 



Posted By: Miller
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 15:42

Originally posted by kiyumars

 cruel Mullas who commit all crime in the name of Allah

Can you give us a couple examples of things “Mullahs” have done that are contradictory to the teachings of their religion

 

 

 

 



Posted By: Zagros
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 15:42
No, I wasnt actually referring to you with my statement, it was just my general belief i was stating, and I am aware of the situation in Iran and I am not shocked by what u say. 

-------------


Posted By: Zagros
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 15:46
I take with a pinch of salt a Turkish person saying Iranians are the most ultra-nationalist. Iranians have never banned the language and culture of their ethnic groups that's why all are still alive today in Iran, is the same true in Turkey?

-------------


Posted By: Murtaza
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 15:48

Zagros Purya

If what people write is true, You are trying to destroy a religion because It is not a iranic religion.

 



Posted By: Miller
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 16:07
 

Are they destroying a religion, or are you trying to make your own custom made religion and call it Islam

 

 



Posted By: Zagros
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 16:14

Not me, I advocate religious freedom. Kiyumars is wrong, most people in Iran, if you ask their religion say they are Muslim, even if they do not practice the religion and drink and do other unIslamic things.

Islam is a part of Iran and anyone who denies it is deluded.

Look at the young people here advocating Rafsanjani for the elections, they do not look like obedient and pure muslims like the man they advocate, but I bet if u ask them what their relgiion is they will tell you Muslim.

I personally have no religion and am agnostic, but facts are facts.

The correct thing to say is that Political Islam is dead in iran.



-------------


Posted By: Zagros
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 16:15
http://www.iranian.com/Arts/2005/June/Hashemi/index.html - http://www.iranian.com/Arts/2005/June/Hashemi/index.html

-------------


Posted By: Murtaza
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 16:15
No, Religions comes from God, Neither from a man(salamn farsi) nor a culture(Iranic)


Posted By: Murtaza
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 16:17

No you misunderstood me, I am not telling Iranian people rejected their religion. In fact, I cant blame them for this.

I mean some of iranians(I dont know who many they are) trying to make islam as a Iranic religion.



Posted By: Miller
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 17:30
 

No, this is not an Iranian led conspiracy. The academic teaching for a long time (long before Islamic revolution in Iran) has been that Iranic religions have influenced the the surviving western religions (Judaism, Christianity, and Islam) to large degree. Traditionally that information does not get publicized outside the academic world but now some Iranian are discovering the information and connect the dots. You can read this information and decide for yourself if it is true or not, or you can blame the messenger for telling you about something

 

 



Posted By: Behrouz
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 18:27
In this thread we have two groups of people living in two different worlds. We have those who have researched religions and look at them academically (this usually means that the person begins to realize all religions are just a sham) and those who are only responding due to their faith in some religion (religion is often so fused to their brain that they won't easily be able to see beyond it).

I think it's pointless to argue something like this, unless you first argue and agree on the base on which you are making your points on. As long as some of you believe that religions are actually sent from god, and some of you believe they're all man-made you can't argue about anything else. First argue about this matter, and if you agree on one base(you won't agree on it, trust me ) then get to higher level stuff like "so who made this religion up anyways?"


Posted By: magavan
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 18:35
Originally posted by Cyrus Shahmiri

lol magavan, don't make it "racist"!

Murtaza, "living under an Islamic state" has had a big effect on Iranians, it is a fact that some Iranians really hate Islam and some others try to make it Iranian!

I do not make it racist because i do not believe in races, there is just ONE race: human race.

But I believe in the evolution of religion 

 Islam will desepear  from Iran.



Posted By: Miller
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 20:59
 

Behrouz, I think you are generalizing a little. Not everyone analyzing a religion believes that all religions are just a sham, and not everyone believing in a faith has done that by closing his or her eyes and ears to reality

 



Posted By: ramin
Date Posted: 12-Jun-2005 at 22:16
Originally posted by magavan


Islam as tokhme Iran miad, Donia as tokhme Iran miad.
Everything in this world come from  arya-vaeja / Arya-varta.
bullsh*t. There's not even a THEORY supporting that.

Originally posted by Land of Aryan

Hey People Azimuth RETURNS!!!!!

& Thanks god , all Humans aren't ARAB, If they were, still grave their girls, still victimize own son to god, still were in desert follow Lizards, still burn books & says we have Quran

Originally posted by azimuth

yes sure he was the real mohammed. he also created christanity judaisim and all other religions. everthing came from iran , iran is the world and the world is iran. human are actully iranian and then they became humans.

Why not????LOL

Land of Aryan, you make me think... think... and think.

Guys, I've to agree with Purya that Islam in Iran is dead (Almost if not completely). just talk to people who live in LA or TO, ask them what's your religion, in many cases you'll get "Zoraostrian" or like in my ex-girlfiend's case "Christian"!

Originally posted by Murtaza

No, Religions comes from God, Neither from a man(salamn farsi) nor a culture(Iranic)
What about Buddhism?!

Originally posted by Murtaza

I mean some of iranians(I dont know who many they are) trying to make islam as a Iranic religion.
I assure you they are not alot. these people (Magavan, Land of Aryan) are even smaller than the smallest minority who believe such thing, and if they believe in such stuff it is a cause of "practiced" Islam in todays Iran. They want to blame someone and who's better than the religion itself? you get my point?


At the end, I support Behrouz's suggestion. when you finished that then you can come and reject each other's beliefs!


-------------
"I won't laugh if a philosophy halves the moon"


Posted By: Behi
Date Posted: 13-Jun-2005 at 04:46

Originally posted by Mortaza

I always think Dunya is a  Turkish word

Infact I dont care if they hate islam, Or If they change their religion.

But pls dont change my religion.


lol, As I said always Turks thinks every thing is Turk, it is Epidemic between them.
Is there any one who force Mortaza to read posts & & force him to change religion.

Originally posted by Mortaza

I am not blaming anyone, but noone have right to destroy my religion too.

are you only one who is beleive in this Religion??????

Originally posted by Zagrus Poria

I take with a pinch of salt a Turkish person saying Iranians are the most ultra-nationalist. Iranians have never banned the language and culture of their ethnic groups that's why all are still alive today in Iran, is the same true in Turkey?

ultra-nationalist!!!!  Remeber Turks 1915, The 1'500'000 Armenian

Originally posted by Zagrus Poria

Not me, I advocate religious freedom. Kiyumars is wrong, most people in Iran, if you ask their religion say they are Muslim, even if they do not practice the religion and drink and do other unIslamic things.

Who has this bravery to say I'm not Muslim anymore in Iran???
except who likes Gallows

Poria: Avaie Dohol az dor shenidan khosh ast

Originally posted by ramin

Land of Aryan, you make me think... think... and think.

Think about?????? what???????

Originally posted by Mortaza

I mean some of iranians(I dont know who many they are) trying to make islam as a Iranic religion.

I don't try to Make it Iranic, it was some information & answer to Azimuth.
All religion is in debt of Zartustra.
Paradise ( even this word is Persian ), hell, Resurrect first come Rartustra
 
for more info refer to:
 L.H.Mills, Our Own Religion in Ancient Persia, la vie future p.255_260
 Sadeghe Hedaiat, Zan va homan iasn ( Bahman Iasht ) p.24
 Azar Faran bogh, Gojastk Abalish



-------------


Posted By: Zagros
Date Posted: 13-Jun-2005 at 05:53

Guys, I've to agree with Purya that Islam in Iran is dead (Almost if not completely). just talk to people who live in LA or TO, ask them what's your religion, in many cases you'll get "Zoraostrian" or like in my ex-girlfiend's case "Christian"!

Sorry but you can't compare Tehrangeles and Tehranto to Tehran.



-------------


Posted By: Zagros
Date Posted: 13-Jun-2005 at 05:55

And was this fguys name not:

SALMAN

RUSHTIE?

I voted traitor because I thought the guy you were talking about was the general that converted to Islam and helped the ISlmaic armies against Iran.

Salman Rushtie is not even Iranian, he is an Indian.



-------------


Posted By: Behi
Date Posted: 13-Jun-2005 at 07:40

Originally posted by Zagros Purya

http://www.iranian.com/Arts/2005/June/Hashemi/index.html - http://www.iranian.com/Arts/2005/June/Hashemi/index.html

lol, Really Funny, Compare to 8 years ago before Khatami at last Rafsanjani period



-------------


Posted By: Zagros
Date Posted: 13-Jun-2005 at 07:50
She is a supporter of Rafsanjani, that is his slogan, "no more talk".

-------------


Posted By: Behrouz
Date Posted: 13-Jun-2005 at 10:59
Originally posted by Miller

 

Behrouz, I think you are generalizing a little. Not everyone analyzing a religion believes that all religions are just a sham, and not everyone believing in a faith has done that by closing his or her eyes and ears to reality

 



If you notice in my post I made sure to include "usually" and "often" to project the idea that maybe a minority don't fall strickly within that catagory.

From personal observation I have noted that most religious people haven't researched their religions at all because if they did, they probably would have seen the problems with it and start questioning things and finally won't be religous anymore.


Posted By: azimuth
Date Posted: 16-Jun-2005 at 08:12
Originally posted by Land of Aryan

Originally posted by Mortaza

I mean some of iranians(I dont know who many they are) trying to make islam as a Iranic religion.

I don't try to Make it Iranic, it was some information & answer to Azimuth.
All religion is in debt of Zartustra.
Paradise ( even this word is Persian ), hell, Resurrect first come Rartustra
 
for more info refer to:
 L.H.Mills, Our Own Religion in Ancient Persia, la vie future p.255_260
 Sadeghe Hedaiat, Zan va homan iasn ( Bahman Iasht ) p.24
 Azar Faran bogh, Gojastk Abalish

Zartustra's existince has a big error if you dont know almost all history encyclopedia's mention his existance in the 7th century BC while others suggesting it was like 3800 BC

and where he was born? judaisim started for sure somewhere 1200 BC and prophets mentioned in judaisim chirstianity and islam are from different times and almost nothing there gives credit to persia.

and by having some words similarity is not really a proof and people who made these "Studies" are like everybody else trying to be famouse by making new theories. which obviosly not accepted my the majority of the people.

not even famouse enough.

 

 



-------------


Posted By: Zagros
Date Posted: 16-Jun-2005 at 09:57
not just some words, but entire concepts.  I suspect u have no idea of the impact the Zaroastrian clergy had on the hebrews after Cyrus freed them from Babylon. Well, let me tell you just one not very important one, they turned Judaism into a monotheistic religion.

-------------


Posted By: azimuth
Date Posted: 16-Jun-2005 at 22:37

Originally posted by Zagros Purya

not just some words, but entire concepts.  I suspect u have no idea of the impact the Zaroastrian clergy had on the hebrews after Cyrus freed them from Babylon. Well, let me tell you just one not very important one, they turned Judaism into a monotheistic religion.

this tiny paragraph will rise lots of questions.

such as what was Judaism before the persians get controle of Babylon?

whats the proofs that Zaroastrians has been impacted judaism? why not the judaism impacted zaroastrians.

is zaroastrian religion the same from its founders time? or it has developed through the years?

since its not clear when zaroaster was born and the place of his birth , what are the proofs that he founded this religion?

even so what makes Salman AL-Farisi the one who tought the Prophet Mohammed PBUH the Religion ? so Islam came from Zaroasterians or from christans or from Judaism?

to make it easier for you, lets say Salman tought the Prophet about Zaroster and the Prophet said waw this is great i will go and study some chirstianity and judaisim and add them to the Zarosters religion and make up a new one, and i will call it Islam and people will be called muslim and i will pretend that iam recieving masseges from God and tell the people about it and call these masseges as Quran.

here you go this is a brand new theory for you which combines the Western theories and the Persian theories. so dont wast much time and go and write a book about this and offcourse add some more spices to it.

 

 

 



-------------


Posted By: Behrouz
Date Posted: 17-Jun-2005 at 02:48
Originally posted by azimuth

this tiny paragraph will rise lots of questions.

such as what was Judaism before the persians get controle of Babylon?

whats the proofs that Zaroastrians has been impacted judaism? why not the judaism impacted zaroastrians.

is zaroastrian religion the same from its founders time? or it has developed through the years?

since its not clear when zaroaster was born and the place of his birth , what are the proofs that he founded this religion?

even so what makes Salman AL-Farisi the one who tought the Prophet Mohammed PBUH the Religion ? so Islam came from Zaroasterians or from christans or from Judaism?

to make it easier for you, lets say Salman tought the Prophet about Zaroster and the Prophet said waw this is great i will go and study some chirstianity and judaisim and add them to the Zarosters religion and make up a new one, and i will call it Islam and people will be called muslim and i will pretend that iam recieving masseges from God and tell the people about it and call these masseges as Quran.

here you go this is a brand new theory for you which combines the Western theories and the Persian theories. so dont wast much time and go and write a book about this and offcourse add some more spices to it.

 


If I'm not mistaken there are books about this "theory", maybe not in English though and also I remember reading somewhere that Salman became a christian for a while, or at least got familiar with their religion and travelled around a bit.

It seems like a plausible theory, it makes sense if Islam was created with the help of Salman, since we already know for a fact that Mohammad was not able to read and write at all.

So all it takes for this theory to be credible is if the person doesn't believe in a miracle that allowed this illiterate person come up with Quran.

Again , as I said before, as long as some people believe in supernatural and others don't, it's impossible to argue about this matter.



Posted By: Afghanan
Date Posted: 17-Jun-2005 at 21:40

I dont think the religion Islam is what makes Iranians angry, but more the fact that Arabs imposed that religion on Persians.  Zoroastrianism, in its basic principles, isnt that far from Islam. 

Zoroaster taught the existence of an uncreated Supreme Diety, Ahura Mazda (Wise Lord), creator of material and spiritual worlds, creator of both light and darkness, founder of the moral order, lawgiver, and judge of all beings.  This isnt that far away from what Muslims believe in God as well.

Im not that familiar with Salman Farsi, but in today's contexts, even Persia would be considered part of the "Axis of Evil" so I dont know if we can judge them by today's standards.



-------------
The perceptive man is he who knows about himself, for in self-knowledge and insight lays knowledge of the holiest.
~ Khushal Khan Khattak


Posted By: HulaguHan
Date Posted: 19-Jun-2005 at 13:27

Originally posted by Murtaza

No, Religions comes from God, Neither from a man(salamn farsi) nor a culture(Iranic)

 

Islam comes from Arabic culture. 5 times a day we listen to arabic radio. I see Turks saltuing each other selam alaykum.

I read Turkish history again and again. It writes we ruled arabs.

but results show they ruled us. 



Posted By: erwin rommel
Date Posted: 10-Feb-2006 at 16:07

hey you fool persians arent you that we arab ruled for almost 700 years ,in lessthan 6 years.........

you were our slaves for all that peirod and how you dare to make these false theory about salman al farsi who we muslim and arab considere him as great moslem man.

i know some persian guys and nobody talk about salman al farsi that bad.

mayby because they are in arab country and they are  so chicken sh*t totalk about something like this.i dont care about shi and sunnie things beside that im sunniets.this forum not for racist things about arian and arabs and turks. 

finaly let the iranian go to hell with aryan mythologies,i respest european so much specialy germans because germans are warlikes and militrist not like you persian that we make you our slaves 4 seven centuries.

 

    

 



Posted By: Maziar
Date Posted: 10-Feb-2006 at 21:44

Erwin Rommel ever read the forum rules?

I will report this post to the moderators.



-------------


Posted By: ramin
Date Posted: 10-Feb-2006 at 23:49
Originally posted by erwin rommel

hey you fool persians arent you that we arab ruled for almost 700 years ,in lessthan 6 years.........

you were our slaves for all that peirod and how you dare to make these false theory about salman al farsi who we muslim and arab considere him as great moslem man.

i know some persian guys and nobody talk about salman al farsi that bad.

mayby because they are in arab country and they are  so chicken sh*t totalk about something like this.i dont care about shi and sunnie things beside that im sunniets.this forum not for racist things about arian and arabs and turks. 

finaly let the iranian go to hell with aryan mythologies,i respest european so much specialy germans because germans are warlikes and militrist not like you persian that we make you our slaves 4 seven centuries.

        Thank you.



-------------
"I won't laugh if a philosophy halves the moon"


Posted By: Behi
Date Posted: 11-Feb-2006 at 04:54
Who are you??
You are which of those baned buddy??

Excelent, you are genius guy, at 1st post as newcommer find old old topic among many forums

IGNORED


-------------


Posted By: azimuth
Date Posted: 11-Feb-2006 at 05:49

closed



-------------



Print Page | Close Window

Bulletin Board Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 9.56a - http://www.webwizforums.com
Copyright ©2001-2009 Web Wiz - http://www.webwizguide.com