an interesting question.

What about:

A warning for you and if you continue a Ban will follow 

 For being Racist and Continues Insults

edited for Racisim and Insults.

Islamic World and Pre-Islamic Arabia

sounds good too since Arabian Peninsula was most of the time independent from persian and roman empies.  while the Berbers were under the Romans since BC and before that they will fall under the Ancient History forum.

so the latests names are

1- Middle East and North Africa
     a - Pre-Islamic History to the rise of Islam until the fall of the Ottomans OR

     b - Middle Easterns and North Africans, such as Arabs, Berbers, and Jews OR

    c - Middle Easterns and North Africans from 1st to 19th Century AD.

2-  Islamic World, Middle East and North Africa
     Islamic and Pre-Islamic History until the fall of the Ottomans

3- Pre-Islamic Arabia and Islamic World
     Pre-Islamic Arabia to the Rise of Islam to the fall of the Ottomans

4- Islamic World
     From the Prophet Mohammed to the fall of the Ottoman Empire

If you ask me this "Islamic World" is the best but it is a good suggestion to make poll.

I think the problem is just for some Arabic dynasties before Islam, so we can use "Islamic World and Pre-Islamic Arabia".

Please just ignore provocative posts guys,

I think the possible forum names such as "Middle East and North Africa" would be unfair to the all other middle Eastern subjects' and rulers' histories, including Romans, Turks and Persians. Middle East and Northern Africa have strong historical bonds btw other Mediterranian regions, Iran and even Central Asia. Limiting it with just Arabs, Hebrews and Berberis wont be fair at all.

I suggest something like the second option.

they had identity, hisory and culture before islam.

the thing is that Islam Came so Big that it shadowed all that.

who is the " moron" we should ban ?

Personally I don't see anything wrong with Islamic world and I am not sure why it should change, but that is just my humble opinion. The term middle east and north africa covers a lot history and it would include many of other forums in here. You are going to use that term meaning to point to a very small portion of middle east history which would be mis-leading, and azimuth I am not being paranoid just stating my opinion

Before and after Islam = The whole history - Islam!

I think for satisfying both Al Bedawi and hani, we can use this one:

Middle East and North Africa
Middle Easterns and North Africans, such as Arabs, Berbers, and Jews

However they were mostly ruled by Persians, Romans and Turks!

Any title that could link the pre-islamic history of people outside arabian peninsula to arab would be a misrepresentation of history. There are a lot arab nationalist web sites that do that already why would you want to change this one