Pakistanis and Indians same?

I did said you are entitle to your opinion...but then your opinion do not matter much for you are just an individual...you views are representative of Pashtons of occupation pashtonistan as the view of OBL is that of Muslims. Indeed you need to realize that Afghan nationalism in pashonistan is not dead. What happened over the years is that the Pakistani conveniently nurtured in its place an Islamic Nationalism, which defied geographic boundaries among Muslims.(radicalization of Pashton youth in Pakistais run Madrassa) This way, they entered an alliance with the old Pashton yearning for unity with their brethren in their father/mother land�-Afghanistan, while keeping the rest of Pakistan intact�hence the Pakistani invasion of Afghanistan. It was a clever ploy on the part of Islamabad, but it always remained vulnerable to a re-emergence of Afghan nationalism.

no there is no political agent... there is no collective punishment...no there is no Pakistani state funded Maddrassa� NO-- the secular Political parties are not banned from FATA. You are trying to make a false point..it seems like you are emotionally attach I might have touched a nerves or something.

The fact is that Taliban and their like are result of Pakistani state design against pashtons� you need to ask youself a simple question where those the motivation for that ideology of Taliban comes from? � Deobandi School of Thought? and many others of the type, Paki state-funded mufties, and Paki State sponsored Mullahs? Where this religious ideology comes from? Do you know that all these things are not indigenous to the Pashtons at all? Pashtons being a proud nation/ethnicity with history going back thousand of years do not need a religious identity. In other words the use of religion as a means for acquiring political power either in Afghanistan or in Pakistan. In fact the crisis of identity is with the Panjabi state Pakistan..which needs religion to bind it together in the absence of any meaningful contract between the various groups for a collective well being of all its citizens.

Afghanistan status as buffer state(what you call "modern afghan state") signifies what was left of Afghan empire drawn by the blood of her own people... we are not a artificial fake state bestow as result of more then 200 faithful servitude to Saheeb(Parangees).    

The reason Afghanistan has been in turmoil is because of division of Afghanistan and pashtonistan...as long as the forward police of Kafir Saheeb is carried by brown Saheeb under FATA and PATA there will be no peace in Afghanistan. As long as the filth of Durrand and Dewband is around there will be more turmoil! 

Now as for as what you call yourself or not.. .as i said you only present yourself--an individual but if you are indeed  from Khyber Agency--FATA then open your identity card(Shenakhtee Pas) your ethnic and race are written as Afghan!     

Now you can wear Dahto, dance Bangra, speak Indic and eat Daal and spicy food� and even call yourself proud Mexican for all I care.  

Khatak being a true Afghan nationalist knows that these poor Afghan refugee nurtured in Pakistani refugee ghettos and indoctrinated in Pakistani immoral �madrassahs� so to wage Pakistani�s coward nations wars against India and Afghanistan�thus in order to break the Pakistani state murderous culture of Jahad it is a must that the refugee ghettos must be closed. All afghan nationalist want the to brea the unholy influences of Pakistani Madrassah on our village people. This idea is nothing knew.. during 1920s Afghan king Ghazi Ammanullah Khan banned Dewbandi education mullah from Afghan mosque.. a new Maddrasa was established in north of Kabul to train new mullahs.

Here is what ANP chief AsfandYar Wali Khan says about his Afghan heritage.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KGSt5g8ltw4&feature=related

Rough translation�.

�Qazi Hussan Ahmad told Mushraf in front of me that ANP statets that �Lar aw bar Yaw Afghan� Upper and lower all one Afghan(Peshware and Kabul all one Afghan) Musharaf told me  is it true� I told him General Saheeb off course its true...I do believe Lar aw Bar yaw Afghan and then I Musrhaf to ask Qazi Hussan Ahmad and Mullawi FazilRahman that when the buy a land�or a new home in the paper work when it ask for their ethnic/race what they put? Mushraf ask me what it written.. I told him to ask Qazi Hussan Ahmad why you are asking me.. Qazi Hussan Ahmad did not answer but Mullawi Fazilrahman said the ethnic/race is written by Pashton as Afghan.�