The Aryan Invasion Debate

Aa many of you may have learned from this site that the Aryan Invasion theory of India is under some serious fire. And although i do not believe in the Aryan Invasion theory and do believe that the Aryans emigrated from India to Europe and Asia but i think that idea is need of some concrete solid evidence, the Gundestrup seal is the only one that i can think of, and the fact that the Indo-European Mitanni people had a horse training manual written entirely in almost pure Sanskrit and that they had Indo-Aryan Names for kings and Gods suggesting that they belonged to the Indo-Aryan branch as the traces of Indo-Aryan tribes moving from India as the only evidence for this migration from India. So i think that this matter should now be dealt with caution and students should be told that it is an open debate and right now anyhing regarding the origin of the Aryans is a point of debate and it should be dealt as such rather than just teaching them that the Aryan Invasion of India did happen. Some neutral treaties should be compiled which should present both side of the debate and wherever such a lengthy matter cannot be given full treatment just include that

"Previously it was assumed that the Aryan Invasion Theory was correct, but recently several discoveries have challenged this notion and currently this subject is a matter of scholarly debate."

New light wll be shed on this topic in the light of new perpectives on the currently known facts but most of the hard evidence for this would come form archeology. The Indus script is a key matter in this debate because if reveals an Aryan language then it will completely invalidate the Aryan Invasion Theory if it doesn't then the Aryan Invasion or Aryan Immigratoin theory will be upheld. I have my fingers crossed because hopfully we may find a bilingual text between a known script like the Armaic or bangani script or more likely a cuneform script as the trade between the Indus Valley Civilization and that of Sumer is well attested as several Indus Valley seals have been unearthed in Mesopotamia, after all Cyrus famed cylindercal seal was unearthed in Mesopotamia not in what is current Iran sites. And we may stumble onto a large body of Indus text in the Indus Valley Civilization helping to decipher the Indus script. Anyway we ware in for quite exciting times.

Hey Irani you say that iranian and indian look nothing like eachother you are right just as the Italian look nothing like the Germans, the Spanish look nothing like the slavs and the slavs look nothing like the Balts and the Balts look nothing like the Scandenavians. The difference in appearance of people occurs everywhere. So it should not be to much of a surprise that the Aryan population of Eurpe looks much more like the non Aryan population of Europe than the Aryan population of Europe looks like the Aryan population of Iran or India. We are talking about the transfer of language and culture by a few elit people although in the case of Iran the transfer of people form India also did took place.