Pakistani Identity

Yea, he "united" the subcontinent for 34 years. Wow, a perfect reason to label 5000 years history to the whole subcontinent.

We need to face that the Indus Valley has always had a distinct identity. And I have lots of examples to back that up.

In India language chages every 50 miles.Differnt sub-cultures and different types of people .

Edited by innocent - 23-May-2007 at 00:46

Well Pakistan also has a vast variety of languages...indeed.

Entire India even though is diverse is linked to a common high level culture and which also similar to pakistan.

First off South Asians were never united.Second off unity means nothing.The people of Eastern Europe and central asia were united under the Soviet banner.Hey wait a minuite that means Central Asians=East Europeans doesn't it?

Originally posted by Distel First off South Asians were never united.

with the exceptions already provided, though maybe those in the deep south of India have a better arguement than those in pakistan's punjab

greeks and Macedonains have shared history but doesnt mean Alexandar was greek.The Indus did stranch into parts of India,but it still originates in pakistan.Indus streches till Turkmenistan and Iran, no claims over iranian and Turkmen history by Indians why?

Bad geography? Say did you even know the indus had colonies going all the way to Turkmenistan? You didn't know that did you? And now you come here to claim the indus for india when you don't even know the limits of it's (the indus) colonies.

lol, Omar is the last person on this forum who needs to prove who he is. He has been a part of AE longer than any of us have, and anyone who has read all his posts can clearly see he NOT an Indian claiming to be someone else. I can fully accept that he is who he says he is, and i think any reasonable person here can as well.

Notice that he is a Moderator. All the Moderators at AE are well respected and trusted in the community. I'm afraid you are alone in your doubts.

It seems that Omar has developed his own beliefs separate from what you expect him to believe, and for that, he is unfortunately getting pounded and dismissed by his own brethren.

I have not actively been a part of this community for that long, but i have been here from before Omar became Moderator, and i will vouch that Omar is who he says he is. Not that he needs me to. Or that this will change any of your views, as you will simply dismiss it by saying, "typical. It's cause ur Indian, so of course you'll show support," which, in a black and white world, doesn't make any sense because he is Pakistani and therefore i should being trying to discredit him.

And as for the name, the electrician i hired the other day is named Aristo, and he is a Hindu from Goa. It's just a name.


Edited by AlokaParyetra - 25-May-2007 at 23:13