Print Page | Close Window

Convert Hagia Sophia back to a church

Printed From: History Community ~ All Empires
Category: Scholarly Pursuits
Forum Name: Intellectual discussions
Forum Discription: Discuss political and philosophical theories, religious beliefs and other academic subjects
URL: http://www.allempires.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=8603
Printed Date: 24-Apr-2024 at 21:46
Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 9.56a - http://www.webwizforums.com


Topic: Convert Hagia Sophia back to a church
Posted By: R_AK47
Subject: Convert Hagia Sophia back to a church
Date Posted: 25-Jan-2006 at 22:36
Are there any active movements attempting to reconvert hagia sophia (in Istanbul) back into an orthodox church?  It seems that there are already plenty of mosques in Istanbul.  It would seem that conversion of the building back to a church would be good tourism and promote friendly relations between Turkey and Greece.  Please list any online sources.



Replies:
Posted By: Loknar
Date Posted: 25-Jan-2006 at 22:40

I dont see why they wouldnt, they are kissing European ass all the time anyway!

 

IN all seriousness, they conquored it, it's theirs. I think its a museum now.



Posted By: Omar al Hashim
Date Posted: 25-Jan-2006 at 23:08
I believe it is a museum now, partly or wholely but I may be wrong.

Besides why would you want to?


Posted By: Mira
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 02:27
Convert all monuments in Spain to back mosques then  


Posted By: Mortaza
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 03:21

I think,   If It   will converted, It would be turned mosque back,  not  church.

 



Posted By: Cywr
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 04:31
There is some organisation of Greeks and Russians who want to at least be able to perform certain rites in there once in a while, so that it sort of reverts to a part time church or something. Don't see much happening on that front though.

Would be neat if they could make it into a Church/Mosqur combo, but considerign Christianity and Islam are rather vain religions, and considering the sheer political and religious symbolism of that most grandest of Roman chruches, which would later go on to inspire an entire style of mosque building, i think thats a pipe dream.


-------------
Arrrgh!!"


Posted By: Constantine XI
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 04:48
It would be nice to make it a tourist attraction/church/mosque. But the religious stakeholders would never agree to it. Best to leave it as a secular building.

-------------


Posted By: Mortaza
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 05:05

I dont think goverment may take such a risky steps. 

Firstly there are not so high demant to turn  it mosque,but  there is a large opposal against changing it church.(Infact I dont remember anyone who even mention it.

Secondly it  will increase  holliness  of istanbul.(this is less wanted thing)

Third,It can create some conflicts.



Posted By: Lmprs
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 05:48
I think Hagia Sophia should remain as a museum.

Originally posted by Mortaza

Secondly it will increase holliness of istanbul.(this is less wanted thing)

What do you mean?


Posted By: Mortaza
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 05:55

easy  with our acceptance or not,  istanbul is somewhat holy  for orthodox.

why do you think, we dont  like  ecumenlik word?

If Aya Sofia turned to church, a lot  believer  would  come to pray at ayasofia. I dont think, we want istanbul  as a capital of orthodox words.(something like rome)

Remember patric of fener  is same position with pope of katholics.

 

 



Posted By: Richard XIII
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 07:42
Originally posted by Mortaza

If Aya Sofia turned to church, a lot  believer  would  come to pray at ayasofia. I dont think, we want istanbul  as a capital of orthodox words.(something like rome)

Remember patric of fener  is same position with pope of katholics.

 


But you'll make a lot of money.

patriarch of fener is not in same position like pope, there is a patriarch in every major orthodox country and they are egual in rights, patriarch of constantinopole is just first of them from  an historical point of view.

Sophia must remain museum.



-------------
"I want to know God's thoughts...
...the rest are details."

Albert Einstein


Posted By: The Guardian
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 07:45

Originally posted by R_AK47

Are there any active movements attempting to reconvert hagia sophia (in Istanbul) back into an orthodox church?  It seems that there are already plenty of mosques in Istanbul.  It would seem that conversion of the building back to a church would be good tourism and promote friendly relations between Turkey and Greece.  Please list any online sources.

Because it's a historical landmark.  Fatih Turned it into a mosque when he conquered it 500 years ago, so it'S a museum now.



-------------
It's just a job. Grass grows, birds fly, waves pound the sand. I beat people up.
                             &nb


Posted By: The Guardian
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 07:50
Originally posted by Mortaza

If Aya Sofia turned to church, a lot  believer  would  come to pray at ayasofia. I dont think, we want istanbul  as a capital of orthodox words.(something like rome)

No.You don't want it to be that way, not many people.Personally, I would like foreigners visiting Istanbul.  I see no reason why not.  Can you tell me?  Or is it just because of some prejudiced opinion of yours?



-------------
It's just a job. Grass grows, birds fly, waves pound the sand. I beat people up.
                             &nb


Posted By: Mortaza
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 08:16

But you'll make a lot of money.

That is  true, but dangers can come with this money too.

patriarch of fener is not in same position like pope, there is a patriarch in every major orthodox country and they are egual in rights, patriarch of constantinopole is just first of them from  an historical point of view.

I  know this, but  IIRC pope and patriarch of fener treat each other like both of them  equal position.

No.You don't want it to be that way, not many people.

wanna ask it your own goverment? It is them who dont like  ecumenlic thing not me.

Personally, I would like foreigners visiting Istanbul. 

Noone  is  against it. Specialy  If they comes with money.

I see no reason why not. 

It looks like  goverment can see.

Can you tell me? 

If you can read some history, you can  learn  reason, and you can learn how russia used  orthodox  right against ottomans.

what do you  think,If  Ayasofia turn  church?  dont you think, other orthox  county would have  words over it?(specialy russia) why  should turkey take this risk? some tourist and money.

Or is it just because of some prejudiced opinion of yours?

no, not my  opinion, infact I support church-mosque aya sofia thing, I dont think that place deserve to be only a stupid museum.

 

 



Posted By: The Guardian
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 08:26
Originally posted by Mortaza

No.You don't want it to be that way, not many people.

wanna ask it your own goverment? It is them who dont like  ecumenlic thing not me.

I see no reason why not. 

It looks like  goverment can see.

Can you tell me? 

If you can read some history, you can  learn  reason, and you can learn how russia used  orthodox  right against ottomans.

what do you  think,If  Ayasofia turn  church?  dont you think, other orthox  county would have  words over it?(specialy russia) why  should turkey take this risk? some tourist and money.

Or is it just because of some prejudiced opinion of yours?

no, not my  opinion, infact I support church-mosque aya sofia thing, I dont think that place deserve to be only a stupid museum.

1-It's museum now, which is why our government is agianst it's conversion

2-Our government is also a conservative one, so them thinking the conversion of Haghia Sophia is bad does not interest me

3-Yes, I bet all the people that suggest the conversion are Russian spies and they are a part of a 200 year old conspiracy

4-Stupid museum?Yes I can see your deep knowledge on highia Sophia from that



-------------
It's just a job. Grass grows, birds fly, waves pound the sand. I beat people up.
                             &nb


Posted By: Mortaza
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 08:38

1-It's museum now, which is why our government is agianst it's conversion.

errrr? realy realy good reason?

2-Our government is also a conservative one, so them thinking the conversion of Haghia Sophia is bad does not interest me

so do you think our politics about this topics  change with  goverment? This politics comes from long long before. Your knowledge about turkey politic is not much large is it? dont you know this islamic goverment is more open about minority  rights? They even try to open, heybeliada school?

3-Yes, I bet all the people that suggest the conversion are Russian spies and they are a part of a 200 year old conspiracy

did I said something like  this? I just  ignore this, no need even to reply. If you will talk instead of me, at least talk with  logic. I wont say some thing so much stupid.

Stupid museum?Yes I can see your deep knowledge on highia Sophia from that

yes it  is a stupid museum, neither mosque not church only one of hundreds museum.

 



Posted By: Lmprs
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 08:39
Originally posted by Mortaza

no, not my opinion, infact I support church-mosque aya sofia thing, I dont think that place deserve to be only a stupid museum.

Explains a lot...


Posted By: Mortaza
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 09:03

Explains a lot...



Posted By: Lmprs
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 10:45
We have more than enough mosques...


Posted By: R_AK47
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 11:34

Originally posted by Mira

Convert all monuments in Spain to back mosques then  

We could trade the mosque of Cordoba in Spain back to Islam in exchange for Hagia Sophias return to status as a church.  I doubt the government of Spain would be interested in that idea though.



Posted By: R_AK47
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 11:39
I think converting Hagia Sophia back to a church would help, not hurt Turkey.  As stated above, they would probably make large amounts of money from this.  Turkey has plenty of mosques already, including several huge ones in Istanbul.  Why so much resistance to one church?


Posted By: Lmprs
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 12:27
Hagia Sophia is a museum right now, not a mosque.


Posted By: Lmprs
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 12:28
Originally posted by R_AK47

We could trade the mosque of Cordoba in Spain back to Islam in exchange for Hagia Sophias return to status as a church. I doubt the government of Spain would be interested in that idea though.

Are you five years old?


Posted By: Mila
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 13:08
If I was in charge - it would officially remain a museum. However, Orthodox Christians would be able to hold services and other rites there whenever they wanted. A special section of the church, the most important section, would be separated for this purpose. They would have free reign to come and go there as they please - for weddings, for baptisms, whatever they wanted. The only condition would be they must not object to a constant flow of tourists in the other parts of the museum and in many cases on the edges of this section, watching. They themselves would become part of the attraction, which wouldn't be too devastating as I imagine Orthodox Christians make up a significant part of Hagia Sofia's tourism anyway.

A living history, something very special for tourists - and, in every way but on paper, a functioning church for Christians.


-------------
[IMG]http://img272.imageshack.us/img272/9259/1xw2.jpg">


Posted By: Mila
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 13:11
And I hope that doesn't sound offensive to Christians - I don't mean to turn them into dancing monkies for tourists. I don't believe it would be like that. I would whole-heartedly support the same thing from an Islamic perspective in Spain. Allowing the local Muslims and tourists to use the religious relics for religious rites but not banning tourists would be a beautiful openness that I'd be very proud of, not offended by.

-------------
[IMG]http://img272.imageshack.us/img272/9259/1xw2.jpg">


Posted By: cebeci
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 13:13

hagia sophia will not ever be converted to church

don't waste your time



-------------
history is just a repetation of itself


Posted By: The Guardian
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 13:16
Originally posted by Mortaza

1-It's museum now, which is why our government is agianst it's conversion.

errrr? realy realy good reason?

2-Our government is also a conservative one, so them thinking the conversion of Haghia Sophia is bad does not interest me

so do you think our politics about this topics  change with  goverment? This politics comes from long long before. Your knowledge about turkey politic is not much large is it? dont you know this islamic goverment is more open about minority  rights? They even try to open, heybeliada school?

3-Yes, I bet all the people that suggest the conversion are Russian spies and they are a part of a 200 year old conspiracy

did I said something like  this? I just  ignore this, no need even to reply. If you will talk instead of me, at least talk with  logic. I wont say some thing so much stupid.

Stupid museum?Yes I can see your deep knowledge on highia Sophia from that

yes it  is a stupid museum, neither mosque not church only one of hundreds museum.

It's a museum and a historical landmark-so it cannot be altered, and yes that is a good reason.

I never referred to politics, I just said our government was a conservative one.I never referred to minorities as well.Are my posts unclear?

I was being sarcastic-thought you would understand

Clearly you have no idea what a museum is

P.S.Please improve your grammar, I struggle to understand your posts



-------------
It's just a job. Grass grows, birds fly, waves pound the sand. I beat people up.
                             &nb


Posted By: cebeci
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 13:18

i can hardly imagine a giant mosque standing in the heart of a christian country

it would have been probably destroyed

like nearly 3500 mosques in balcans built by ottomans 

hey dudes history remained unforgooten



-------------
history is just a repetation of itself


Posted By: The Guardian
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 13:18

Originally posted by Mila

If I was in charge - it would officially remain a museum. However, Orthodox Christians would be able to hold services and other rites there whenever they wanted. A special section of the church, the most important section, would be separated for this purpose. They would have free reign to come and go there as they please - for weddings, for baptisms, whatever they wanted. The only condition would be they must not object to a constant flow of tourists in the other parts of the museum and in many cases on the edges of this section, watching. They themselves would become part of the attraction, which wouldn't be too devastating as I imagine Orthodox Christians make up a significant part of Hagia Sofia's tourism anyway.

A living history, something very special for tourists - and, in every way but on paper, a functioning church for Christians.

That's a very nice idea, but have you ever been there?Were will this "special section" be?  If we can take care of that problem there is no reaason not to do it

 



-------------
It's just a job. Grass grows, birds fly, waves pound the sand. I beat people up.
                             &nb


Posted By: Mila
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 13:30
Wherever the altar used to be, wherever the setting is right. It really doesn't matter to me where it is, I imagine the Christians would know the proper place. Nothing is impossible, especially not re-arranging some things in a museum.

-------------
[IMG]http://img272.imageshack.us/img272/9259/1xw2.jpg">


Posted By: cebeci
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 13:46
mila what is your quote sentence about?

-------------
history is just a repetation of itself


Posted By: Mila
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 13:53
Just something I thought was funny. Silly women.

-------------
[IMG]http://img272.imageshack.us/img272/9259/1xw2.jpg">


Posted By: cebeci
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 13:57

oh yeah

nevermind



-------------
history is just a repetation of itself


Posted By: R_AK47
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 19:48

Originally posted by barish

Originally posted by R_AK47

We could trade the mosque of Cordoba in Spain back to Islam in exchange for Hagia Sophias return to status as a church. I doubt the government of Spain would be interested in that idea though.

Are you five years old?

No that was meant to be a joke.  That wouldn't be an even trade anyways, as no mosque is equal to Hagia Sophia.



Posted By: R_AK47
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 19:56
Originally posted by cebeci

hagia sophia will not ever be converted to church

don't waste your time

If a Christian nation is able to reclaim Constantinople, then I imagine it will be, along with the other former churchs that are now mosques.



Posted By: Lmprs
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 20:04
Originally posted by R_AK47

If a Christian nation is able to reclaim Constantinople, then I imagine it will be, along with the other former churchs that are now mosques.

Why can't you understand? Hagia Sophia is a museum, not a mosque! How many times should I repeat it?


Posted By: Guests
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 20:29

I believe that, including the poster opening this topic, none of the posters in this topic would be interested in attending a service there if it were converted to a church.

While supporting the museum decree, I think that, if it had been kept as a mosque it would have been better preserved and refurbished.

Although the museum decree by Atatürk has been appreciated and acclaimed universally since 1935, one only could wonder why someone has still been incapable of comprehension.



Posted By: erci
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 20:30
we should convert it to a mosque again just to piss RAk-471acc329-b off


Posted By: R_AK47
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 21:17
Well, if they must keep it a museum they could at least take those giant, ugly discs with the arabic writing out of the interior.  The minarets should go too.  And then there is that crescent on top of the dome....


Posted By: Omar al Hashim
Date Posted: 26-Jan-2006 at 23:26
Are you deliberately try to provoke people or just plain stupid?


Posted By: erci
Date Posted: 27-Jan-2006 at 00:52

magnificent

tho 2 more minarets would make it even better and maybe a larger crescent on top


Posted By: Omar al Hashim
Date Posted: 27-Jan-2006 at 01:15
Thats a great picture


Posted By: R_AK47
Date Posted: 27-Jan-2006 at 01:19

I prefer this one.  Much better.  But it needs a restored statue of Emperor Justinian placed on the front part of it.



Posted By: R_AK47
Date Posted: 27-Jan-2006 at 01:21

We could rebuild the Church of the Holy Apostles next to Hagia Sophia (where it used to be).



Posted By: TheDiplomat
Date Posted: 27-Jan-2006 at 02:41

Originally posted by Omar al Hashim

I believe it is a museum now, partly or wholely but I may be wrong.

Besides why would you want to?

Exactly,my Pakistani friend...

This thread is nothing more than a garbage as the title suggests....

 



-------------
ARDA:The best Turkish diplomat ever!



Posted By: The Guardian
Date Posted: 27-Jan-2006 at 04:12

Originally posted by Mila

Wherever the altar used to be, wherever the setting is right. It really doesn't matter to me where it is, I imagine the Christians would know the proper place. Nothing is impossible, especially not re-arranging some things in a museum.

No really the interior has been quite changed, so it would be difficult.  Plus there is another problem, some people would not want it changed(like mortaza).  They would make life very hard for you if you made an attempt to change it



-------------
It's just a job. Grass grows, birds fly, waves pound the sand. I beat people up.
                             &nb


Posted By: R_AK47
Date Posted: 27-Jan-2006 at 23:20
So what if the interior has been changed.  It can easily be changed back to the way it used to/should be.  I wonder what the greek/orthodox members on AE think about this.  I have not seen any posts from them on this subject.


Posted By: Leonidas
Date Posted: 28-Jan-2006 at 04:57
  R_AK47 wrote:
"I have not seen any posts from them on this subject."
actually you dont here much with me coz i already raised constantinople http://www.allempires.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=5862&PN=10&TPN=7 - - further

I want them restored, i think its the right thing to do, but that is wishful thinking. In the end it will be up to the turks not the greeks on what happens with those buildings.
http://www.allempires.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=5862&PN=10&TPN=8 -


Posted By: Leonidas
Date Posted: 28-Jan-2006 at 06:18
@R_AK47
do you have to start a million threads on this?


Posted By: R_AK47
Date Posted: 28-Jan-2006 at 13:39

Originally posted by Leonidas

  R_AK47 wrote:
"I have not seen any posts from them on this subject."
actually you dont here much with me coz i already raised constantinople http://www.allempires.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=5862&PN=10&TPN=7 - - further

I want them restored, i think its the right thing to do, but that is wishful thinking. In the end it will be up to the turks not the greeks on what happens with those buildings.
http://www.allempires.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=5862&PN=10&TPN=8 -


Posted By: Leonidas
Date Posted: 28-Jan-2006 at 20:47
what about you make one thread with all your issues and stop creating new threads about every church.


Posted By: Alparslan
Date Posted: 29-Jan-2006 at 05:05

Originally posted by R_AK47

Hagia Irene!  I almost forgot about that.  Perhaps I should start a post about Hagia Irene next.  And then there is the Cora Church, SS Sergius and Bachus, and others.

I think you are talking about Aya Irini.... Well, it is well preserved concert hall. It has never converted to a mosque and used as granary in the garden of Topkapi Palace. In 19.th century it has been used as military museum and in year 1993 the restoration works ended and building is still in use as a concert hall. As you see there is a big cross on the top respecting to its past. In Aya Irini there are turkish classical, western classical, religious musics of all religions, modern dance etc. entertainments.

There are tens of Greek Orthodox Churches in Istanbul as you can see from the list below with their addresses that can be used for your religious needs.

We are expecting a mosque, at least one mosque, in Athens for the needs of Muslims. But even for Olympic games a mosque can not be buit in the city. I wonder why? In holy days of Islam, Muslims are praying in the stadiums or empty places. You can make a restoration for Fethiye Mosque of Ottomans in Athens for example. We are hoping that, European Union, the champion of cultural rights, telorance, democracy, human rights, multi-culturalism and every other goods things will also deal with this problem in the future.   The same problem exists for Tessaloniki. Once there were 70 mosques in the city but now it remained only two ruined ones.

We demand only one mosque in Athens and one for Tessaloniki.......

Greek Orthodox  Churches In Istanbul


 

Hagia Yorgi Fener Greek Orthodox
Patriarch Church
Sadrazam Ali Pasa Caddesi No. 35
Fener, Eyup
(212) 531 9670-76
Hagia Triada Greek Orthodox Church
Mesale Sokak No. 11 Taksim
(212) 244 1358
Hagia Nicholas Greek Orthodox Church
Unkapani
 
Hagia Mary Greek Orthodox Church
Tevkii cafer Mektebi Sokak Fener
Hagia Panaya Isodoryon Greek Orthodox Church
Nevruza Sokak Galatasaray
 
Hagia Therapon Greek Orthodox Church
Alemdar Caddesi Sultanahmet Gulhane
Hagia Yorgi Greek Orthodox Church
Buyukada
 
Hagia Nicola Greek Orthodox Church
Heybeli Ada
Hagia Panaya Kamariotissa Greek Orthodox Church
Heybeli Ada
 
Hagia Yorgi Greek Orthodox Church
Heybeli Ada
Hagia Triada Greek Orthodox Church
Heybeli Ada
 
Hagia Dimitri Kanabu Greek Orthodox Church
Kirkambar Sokak No. 12 Balat
Hagia Panaya Elida Greek Orthodox Church
Gerdanlik Sokak No.4 kumkapi
 
Hagia Euphemie Greek Orthodox Church
Muhurdar Caddesi Kadikoy
Hagia Heleni Constantin Greek Orthodox Church
Kalyoncukullugu Caddesi No. 176 Tarlabasi
 
Hagia Salamatomruk Panaya Greek Orthodox Church
salamatomruk caddesi No. 43 Edirnekapi
 
Hagia Yorgi Cypres Greek Orthodox Church
Samatya Caddesi Samatya Kocamustafapasa
 
Hagia Menas Greek Orthodox Church
Bestekar Hakki Bey Sokak No 1 Samatya Kocamustafapasa
 
Hagia Jean Chrysostom Constantinople Greek Orthodox Church
Kalamis Fenerbahce Kadikoy
 
Hagia Yorgi Greek Orthodox Church
Kuleli Caddesi Cengelkoy
 

http://www.istanbulinfolink.com/place_of_worship/churches/christian_4.htm - http://www.istanbulinfolink.com/place_of_worship/churches/ch ristian_4.htm



Posted By: Periander
Date Posted: 29-Jan-2006 at 05:58
Originally posted by Alparslan

We are expecting a mosque, at least one mosque, in Athens for the needs of Muslims. But even for Olympic games a mosque can not be buit in the city. I wonder why? In holy days of Islam, Muslims are praying in the stadiums or empty places. You can make a restoration for Fethiye Mosque of Ottomans in Athens for example. [...]  The same problem exists for Tessaloniki. Once there were 70 mosques in the city but now it remained only two ruined ones.

We demand only one mosque in Athens and one for Tessaloniki.......



I understand the problem as it exists in Athens and in Thessaloniki, however, that is not to say that the very populous Turkish minority in Western Thrace does not enjoy Mosques.

However, if the restoration of the Fethiye Mosque of Ottomans is made, are you saying that Hagia Sophia will be restored to its original owner, the Orthodox Church?


We are hoping that, European Union, the champion of cultural rights, telorance, democracy, human rights, multi-culturalism and every other goods things will also deal with this problem in the future. 


How can this be, for since 1955, when many Greeks from Constantinople/Istanbul were forced to leave from the resultant pogroms, no resititution has been made, nor do Greeks in the city enjoy hereditary rights as their fellow countrymen there.

People, understand that I have no qualm or gripe with Turkiye or its citizens, but this tit-for-tat, tedious quarreling bogs down in circular argumentation with holier-than-thou attitude being displayed, over and over again.

Again, I pick up on the theme of democracy and human rights as posted in the other thread on this same issue.

I believe that Athens should restore the mosques. Are those living in Constantinople/Istanbul willing to make the same concessions?


Posted By: RomiosArktos
Date Posted: 29-Jan-2006 at 06:39
According to the Treaty of Lausanne,the Muslim population of western Thrace and the christian population of Istanbul,Imvros and Tenedos were excluded from the exchange.However,from the initial population of 110.000 christian greeks of Istanbul in 1942,there are only a few now left and the Patriarch,after the pogrom in 1955 and later.Those that left their fortunes back in Istanbul,were not compensated.Also the same happened to the Greeks of Imvros and Tenedos.Their lands were confiscated by the Turkish state.
On the other hand,the Muslim Greek citizens of western Thrace in 1981 were 120.000 and their rights are respected by everyone,as citizens of Greece.They have numerous Mosques and schools for their needs.
Double standards
When Turkey becomes a member of the EU,huge money will be paid to those that suffered from the Turkish pogrom as compensation.You must be prepared to pay..
Why don't you open the theological school of Halki.How can the christian minority educate its priests without  a theological school?
When the Greeks were asked to leave Turkey,it was asked from them to become Muslim,did you know this?




Posted By: Mortaza
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 05:04

errr.

Romios, I think you have no   knowledge what happened at both side.

Firstly greeks left county after they sell their properties, infact They left country because they  afraid of. So I dont know what do you mean with compensated.

So I dont know why turkey should pay greeks.

For greece, it is also not much beatiful, infact greece goverment dont even let turkish minority choose their own muftu.

60.000 turkish citizenship abolished by greece,  and turkish minority can even call themself as turkish.

Why don't you open the theological school of Halki.How can the christian minority educate its priests without  a theological school?

Again this is half-true, Patriach can open this school, but he should accept turkish rules, and this rules are same for imam schools.

 

 


 

 



Posted By: The Guardian
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 05:37

Originally posted by RomiosArktos

According to the Treaty of Lausanne,the Muslim population of western Thrace and the christian population of Istanbul,Imvros and Tenedos were excluded from the exchange.However,from the initial population of 110.000 christian greeks of Istanbul in 1942,there are only a few now left and the Patriarch,after the pogrom in 1955 and later.

There is no such pogrom-shameful things happened-that is right and money will be paid if reuested-but I don't think you know the definiton of pogrom-and that so called "pogrom" is not proven-nor wiely accepted, I think the Greeks are the only people that call it pogrom



-------------
It's just a job. Grass grows, birds fly, waves pound the sand. I beat people up.
                             &nb


Posted By: The Guardian
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 05:39

Originally posted by RomiosArktos

When the Greeks were asked to leave Turkey,it was asked from them to become Muslim,did you know this?

no such thing happened



-------------
It's just a job. Grass grows, birds fly, waves pound the sand. I beat people up.
                             &nb


Posted By: Periander
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 06:01
Originally posted by The Guardian

Originally posted by RomiosArktos

According to the Treaty of Lausanne,the Muslim population of western Thrace and the christian population of Istanbul,Imvros and Tenedos were excluded from the exchange.However,from the initial population of 110.000 christian greeks of Istanbul in 1942,there are only a few now left and the Patriarch,after the pogrom in 1955 and later.

There is no such pogrom-shameful things happened-that is right and money will be paid if reuested-but I don't think you know the definiton of pogrom-and that so called "pogrom" is not proven-nor wiely accepted, I think the Greeks are the only people that call it pogrom



http://forum.axishistory.com/viewtopic.php?t=85438&highlight=istanbul - http://forum.axishistory.com/viewtopic.php?t=85438&highl ight=istanbul

Which contains two points of interest:

a) Newspaper article of a vandalism on an exhibition on the 1955 pogrom

b) Turkish members stating that there was indeed a pogrom, maybe not anti-Greek in focus, but that there was a pogrom with possible political links, the implication being, of course, that the pogrom was an organised event (again, if it was politically driven).

From www.dictionary.com - www.dictionary.com on the word "pogrom":
An organized, often officially encouraged massacre or persecution of a minority group, especially one conducted against Jews.


*Disclaimer: I am not wishing to start a debate on this, nor to stir up anti-Turkish feeling, but a point was made in this thread, which I felt must be addressed since it reeks of *denialism*.


Posted By: Periander
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 06:20
Originally posted by The Guardian

Originally posted by RomiosArktos

When the Greeks were asked to leave Turkey,it was asked from them to become Muslim,did you know this?

no such thing happened




Can you prove that it did not?

By the same token, can Romios prove that it did?

And people, I want sources. (No, Politiki Kouzina = A Touch of Spice does not count.)


Posted By: Zagros
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 08:07

Originally posted by erci


magnificent

tho 2 more minarets would make it even better and maybe a larger crescent on top

Yes, two more HUUUGE minarets to praise allah for giving such a magnificent gift to the people of Islam, and I definately hear you on the crescent.  



-------------


Posted By: Mortaza
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 08:38

When the Greeks were asked to leave Turkey,it was asked from them to become Muslim,did you know this?

Infact noone asked greek to leave, they left istanbul with their own wish, because they didnot want to live with so turks and goverment who have large anti-greek feeling.(for exp the pogrom)

Both church and greece tried to stop them, but they went.

You are talking like turkey exiled them, turkey just  made life difficult for them, they sold their properties, and left the istanbul.(Armenians didnot)



Posted By: R_AK47
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 12:42
Originally posted by Zagros

Originally posted by erci


magnificent

tho 2 more minarets would make it even better and maybe a larger crescent on top

Yes, two more HUUUGE minarets to praise allah for giving such a magnificent gift to the people of Islam, and I definately hear you on the crescent.  

We should take that minaret and shove it up.......



Posted By: Zagros
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 13:47
Allah be praised we will add some minarets to that ugly heap at St Peters one day soon and beautify it too, when Turkey joins the EU that will happen.

-------------


Posted By: Mortaza
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 14:01

errr this is becoming inderesting.



Posted By: Heraclius
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 14:52

Originally posted by Zagros

Allah be praised we will add some minarets to that ugly heap at St Peters one day soon and beautify it too, when Turkey joins the EU that will happen.

 *shudder*



-------------
A tomb now suffices him for whom the world was not enough.


Posted By: Zagros
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 15:28
Shudder!? You shudder?  St Paul's is up for renovation next, you can shudder all u want then

-------------


Posted By: Beylerbeyi
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 15:28

If it is going to end Greek whining, we should convert not only Ayasofya but also Blue Mosque to a church.

Allah be praised we will add some minarets to that ugly heap at St Peters one day soon and beautify it too, when Turkey joins the EU that will happen.

  Aamin. Inshallah, the day will come when the Pope will lead the Friday prayer.



-------------


Posted By: Zagros
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 15:45
alhamdolillah.

-------------


Posted By: Heraclius
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 16:10

Originally posted by Zagros

Shudder!? You shudder?  St Paul's is up for renovation next, you can shudder all u want then

 I'm not even Christian but you touch that damn building and i'll break your neck  



-------------
A tomb now suffices him for whom the world was not enough.


Posted By: Spartakus
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 16:14
Originally posted by Mortaza

 turkey just  made life difficult for them, they sold their properties, and left the istanbul.(Armenians didnot)

Just TOO difficult you mean?

-------------
"There are worse crimes than burning books. One of them is not reading them. "
--- Joseph Alexandrovitch Brodsky, 1991, Russian-American poet, b. St. Petersburg and exiled 1972 (1940-1996)


Posted By: Guests
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 16:53
Originally posted by Mortaza

When the Greeks were asked to leave Turkey,it was asked from them to become Muslim,did you know this?

Infact noone asked greek to leave, they left istanbul with their own wish, because they didnot want to live with so turks and goverment who have large anti-greek feeling.(for exp the pogrom)

I think, he is confused with the deportations after the Cyprus issue. The Greek, living in Istanbul in 1960s without Turkish passports, were deported (after 1963) because of the tension triggered by the massacred Turks in Cyprus.



Posted By: arch.buff
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 20:12

St. Peter and St. Paul architectually islamified?

I would do everything in my power........



Posted By: Maju
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 20:52
I think it's better to make all them museums or post offcies and let the people pray at home if they wish. Too many religious buindings around and too much inter-sectary strife... In USSR they knew better and reycled them into stables (some).


-------------

NO GOD, NO MASTER!


Posted By: Omar al Hashim
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 21:01
I had a picture once of a mosque just below the Vatican. Unfortunately I can't find it now.


Posted By: Quetzalcoatl
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 21:09

 

The price to pay to lose to a foreign culture, your churches are desecrated, your wives and daughters rape and your children to slavery. 

 

France was attempting a last crusade against the Turks during the renaissance, to chase them from Constantinople, that's why we invaded Italy, but it triggered a series of unexpected events and in the end we allied the people we were set to destroy. How ironic.

 

 



-------------


Posted By: Maju
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 21:26
Originally posted by Omar al Hashim

I had a picture once of a mosque just below the Vatican. Unfortunately I can't find it now.


Sure. But we have yet to find a picture of a Hindu temple near the Great Mosque. Tolerance is a multilateral thing.


-------------

NO GOD, NO MASTER!


Posted By: Omar al Hashim
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 21:41
Originally posted by Maju

Originally posted by Omar al Hashim

I had a picture once of a mosque just below the Vatican. Unfortunately I can't find it now.


Sure. But we have yet to find a picture of a Hindu temple near the Great Mosque. Tolerance is a multilateral thing.

Non Catholics aren't allowed in the Vatican. I have no problem with this. (Although I really would love to check out the vatican library one day)


Posted By: Constantine XI
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 21:44

Originally posted by Omar al Hashim

Originally posted by Maju

Originally posted by Omar al Hashim

I had a picture once of a mosque just below the Vatican. Unfortunately I can't find it now.


Sure. But we have yet to find a picture of a Hindu temple near the Great Mosque. Tolerance is a multilateral thing.

Non Catholics aren't allowed in the Vatican. I have no problem with this. (Although I really would love to check out the vatican library one day)

Really? Are you certain that non-Catholics may not enter Vatican city?



-------------


Posted By: Omar al Hashim
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 22:20
I'm pretty sure that only catholic men are. But maybe thats only in certain areas of the vatican


Posted By: R_AK47
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 23:26
Well, it appears that this thread has degenerated into many of us discussing adding and removing minarets from different religious buildings.  I guess we will all just have to wait and see what the fate of Hagia Sophia is.  I do wish someone would invest some money into preserving the building while the rest of us debate its future.  It would be terrible if, after all the arguing, the building was completely deteriorated from neglect (though I have not changed my opinions on what should be done with the building).


Posted By: Omar al Hashim
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 23:42
Its a museum, its not neglected. 


Posted By: Imperator Invictus
Date Posted: 30-Jan-2006 at 23:45
Anyone who is in Rome, whether Christian, Pagan, or Muslim, may enter the Vatican City. I was there a few years back and visited St' Peters and the Museusm. I sure wasn't a catholic.


However, St. Peters does have dress codes you have to adhere to if you want to walk inside.


-------------


Posted By: R_AK47
Date Posted: 31-Jan-2006 at 00:33

Originally posted by Omar al Hashim

Its a museum, its not neglected. 

I read an article somewhere that stated that UNESCO noted falling plaster, deteriorating paint, broken windows, and damaged lead roofing.  It was in an archeology magazine.



Posted By: Periander
Date Posted: 31-Jan-2006 at 03:30
Is this the article you are referring to?

http://www.unesco.org/archi2000/pdf/ozil.pdf - http://www.unesco.org/archi2000/pdf/ozil.pdf


Posted By: R_AK47
Date Posted: 31-Jan-2006 at 10:33
Yes I think that is it.


Posted By: R_AK47
Date Posted: 31-Jan-2006 at 15:44
Where is the large, gold cross that used to be located on the top of the church at now?


Posted By: Mortaza
Date Posted: 31-Jan-2006 at 15:48

haha

latins stolen it.

Go bash them.

 



Posted By: Leonidas
Date Posted: 01-Feb-2006 at 04:11
Mortaza wrote:
"haha

latins stolen it.

Go bash them."

Mortaza, on one thread your talking about religous sensativities over a cartoon and how seroius we westerners should take them. On here you laugh at defacing of a once grand church, despite orthodox sensativities.

Ok i have to get something of my chest,

A couple of posts in responding to AK47 (on both threads) were just as dissapointing and unnessacry as he is annoying. No matter how you feel about some of thse forumers/posts/topics, not all of us deserve to read such insensative posts when we look at these threads. While I do recognise many others did not get tempted to get at  AK47 by making fun of the subject and showed good restraint.

I think there is a bit of double standards when on one 'sensative' subject its all seroius  and on another its . Subjects that are linked to religoius sensativities should have a degree of respect from all sides.




Posted By: Mortaza
Date Posted: 01-Feb-2006 at 04:25

Mortaza, on one thread your talking about religous sensativities over a cartoon and how seroius we westerners should take them. On here you laugh at defacing of a once grand church, despite orthodox sensativities.

No, I am not, I am making fun with  AK47, cant you see,his aim  is  only bash Turks, If his aim is church, I just showed who should be bashed.(I think I played  a sensitive area,I am sorry)

I  am not laughing defacing of Aya Sofia, I am laughing stupity of AK47.

Infact I have great respect for Aya Sofia(both as a church and mosque)




Posted By: Leonidas
Date Posted: 01-Feb-2006 at 04:54
Mortaza wrote:
"No, I am not, I am making fun with  AK47, cant you see,his aim  is  only bash Turks, If his aim is church, I just showed who should be bashed.(I think I played  a sensitive area,I am sorry)"
I know your reasonable and repesctful from past conversations thats why i was disapointed, its cool. There has been too many jokes on the two hagia sophia threads and i think your post was the unlucky last straw. I know i have also been unwittingly insensative in the past so wont go on.

"I  am not laughing defacing of Aya Sofia, I am laughing stupity of AK47."
That was the killer for me but now i know the direction of the laughter. He doesnt know much about turkey, but if he grows up he can learn, (like i have) from the turks here.




Posted By: Zagros
Date Posted: 01-Feb-2006 at 05:11
Originally posted by Leonidas

Mortaza wrote:
"haha

latins stolen it.

Go bash them."

Mortaza, on one thread your talking about religous sensativities over a cartoon and how seroius we westerners should take them. On here you laugh at defacing of a once grand church, despite orthodox sensativities.

Although I am in full agreement over the hypcorisy, this guy has been bashing Turks/Muslims for converting the Hagia Sophia and defeating Byzantium, he is like a Pan Christian nationalist. I think Mortaza was pointing out the irony of the matter as in, "look who stole it! will u go and bash them now? Unlikely!". IMO having a laugh with a guy over his extreme views of what should be done over very very old historical events is not tantamount to making fun of the holy trinity and doing your best to insult Christians. 



-------------


Posted By: DayI
Date Posted: 01-Feb-2006 at 06:18
Originally posted by Mortaza

haha

latins stolen it.

Go bash them.

 

Translation/explanation of this:

R_ak47 says "Where is the large, gold cross that used to be located on the top of the church at now? "

Mortaza wanna say: "Venetians (it whas a horse statue) and the western crusaders stole it, what you gonna do now? Bashing them or find a way to blaim Turks again?"

Ive learnd a lot of things of the Greeks also, if i was the one who should hate Greeks because of a stupid joke (by a guy who doesnt represent all Greek population) i wasnt here for the moment.

 



-------------
Bu mıntıka'nın Dayı'sı
http://imageshack.us - [IMG - http://www.allempires.com/forum/uploads/DayI/2006-03-17_164450_bscap021.jpg -


Posted By: Digenis
Date Posted: 01-Feb-2006 at 18:22
The fact is that a wonder of architecture is collapsing because the state of Turkey unfortunately is not in a satisfying level of culture...

:"restoration" lasts for years and years,just to reduce the beauty of the monument.(everywhere iron staging)
The church is painted red!!! i dont know whose idea was that-to look like the turkish flag maybe ?? and it has to be painted for years.
Low quality fashion shows ,where video screens(!) were used where organised in it.

At least the building survived,and didnt has the end of thousand other medieval greek monuments of Asia Minor that are lost for ever.
1000 years of byzantine presence in Asia minor ...and very few things survived.

Unfortunately Turkey has a loooong way to do,to reach a cultural level similar to the european.Its a better aim to follow before having a desparate hope to enter the European Union.



Posted By: strategos
Date Posted: 01-Feb-2006 at 18:26
There is no reason to convert it back to a church, soon there will be no more greek christians left in Istanbul. That is worse than the Hagia Sophia being a museum.

-------------
http://theforgotten.org/intro.html


Posted By: erci
Date Posted: 01-Feb-2006 at 22:15
why there won't be any greeks left in Istanbul?


Posted By: strategos
Date Posted: 01-Feb-2006 at 22:20

Originally posted by erci

why there won't be any greeks left in Istanbul?

You mean why won't there be any greeks left in istanbul? There are only 2,000 greeks left living there, and most are elderly people.



-------------
http://theforgotten.org/intro.html


Posted By: erci
Date Posted: 01-Feb-2006 at 22:30
ah I see.If the number you gave is correct then why is there a lot of greek churches in Istanbul?
we should close or convert them to museums if they won't be in use


Posted By: strategos
Date Posted: 01-Feb-2006 at 22:37

Originally posted by erci

ah I see.If the number you gave is correct then why is there a lot of greek churches in Istanbul?
we should close or convert them to museums if they won't be in use

Well, Istanbul(Constantinople) did have a big greek christian population at one time.. Besides, Greece has many churches itself, but many are small and only small amounts of people go to them.

Might as well convert them to mosques actually, many mosques are just remade churches.. Museums are fine too.

If you think my number is ridiculous, do you have one then?



-------------
http://theforgotten.org/intro.html


Posted By: R_AK47
Date Posted: 01-Feb-2006 at 23:12
Originally posted by Zagros

Originally posted by Leonidas

Mortaza wrote:
"haha

latins stolen it.

Go bash them."

Mortaza, on one thread your talking about religous sensativities over a cartoon and how seroius we westerners should take them. On here you laugh at defacing of a once grand church, despite orthodox sensativities.

Although I am in full agreement over the hypcorisy, this guy has been bashing Turks/Muslims for converting the Hagia Sophia and defeating Byzantium, he is like a Pan Christian nationalist. I think Mortaza was pointing out the irony of the matter as in, "look who stole it! will u go and bash them now? Unlikely!". IMO having a laugh with a guy over his extreme views of what should be done over very very old historical events is not tantamount to making fun of the holy trinity and doing your best to insult Christians. 

I seem to remember seeing a post on here where you, Zagros, wrote something to the effect of praising Allah and adding more minarets to Hagia Sophia and several Catholic churches.  I believe that is probably as nationalistic as some of my postings.  While some of my ideas may seem extreme, something needs to be done to preserve this building, from what I'm reading it is deteriorating fast.  If returned to Orthodox use, I am sure that the Orthodox community would find the money and resources to preserve it. 

About the cross on the top, I know there was one still there when the city fell in 1453, because I read somewhere about a Turk that climbed to the top to pull it off.  If that was the original one I don't know. 

I have read the posts of other people on these forums.  After seeing so much interest in Byzantium, I thought that more members would support the idea of Hagia Sophia being returned to church status.  Very little of Byzantium survives to this day.  Fortunately, we can still save one of the most impressive remnants of it.



Posted By: Constantine XI
Date Posted: 01-Feb-2006 at 23:27

Originally posted by R_AK47

I have read the posts of other people on these forums.  After seeing so much interest in Byzantium, I thought that more members would support the idea of Hagia Sophia being returned to church status.  Very little of Byzantium survives to this day.  Fortunately, we can still save one of the most impressive remnants of it.

Yes it is true, AE has a sizeable number of Byzantinists, both professional and casual amateurs. But the fact that many of us have an interest in this great civilisation does not necessarily mean we want to go about resurrecting the Byzantine Empire.

The measure proposed is considered a national affront to many who live in the same city as Haghia Sophia. I flippantly commented that it should be turned into a nightclub, flippantly because I believe that Haghia Sophia might as well be turned into a neutral object of public enjoyment rather than something highly divisive that will cause strife and conflict. Terrorist attacks have already occured in Istanbul. If you really care about preserving this legacy of Byzantium, which do you think is less likely to see it attacked by extremists: turning it into a church or leaving it as a secular building for all to enjoy?



-------------



Print Page | Close Window

Bulletin Board Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 9.56a - http://www.webwizforums.com
Copyright ©2001-2009 Web Wiz - http://www.webwizguide.com