Survey
Printed From: History Community ~ All Empires
Category: General History
Forum Name: Military History
Forum Discription: Discussions related to military history: generals, battles, campaigns, etc.
URL: http://www.allempires.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=2111
Printed Date: 08-Jun-2024 at 00:38 Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 9.56a - http://www.webwizforums.com
Topic: Survey
Posted By: Guests
Subject: Survey
Date Posted: 10-Feb-2005 at 18:54
I'd be very interested to have users opinions on:
1) The Greatest General
2) The Greatest Army
3) The Greatest Campaign
4) The Greatest Battle (tactics-wise)
5) The Greatest Battle (purely for heroics)
6) Greatest Rivalry
7) Biggest Upset
8) Most glorious victory
9) The Worst Error
10) Your favorite area of military history
Here's my ideas
1) Hannibal: Napoleon is a sentimental favorite of mine. I had
difficulty choosing between the two, but my final choice was be
Hannibal. Traversing his army across the Alps, and invading Italy. His
campaign there lasted 17 years, nearly half a generation, operating
hundreds of miles from his base of supply, in the heartland of hostile
enemy territory, leading a force of various races, ethnicities,
religions and languages, backed with the greatest tactics to world has
seen, he nearly beat the greatest military power of the Ancient World.
AMAZING!!! This truly proves his leadership as a magnificent general.
How did he do this!
2) The Roman Legions: The Roman Legion, the ultimate military machine
of the ancient world, was the catalyst that spread Roman conquest and
civilization throughout the known world.
3) The campaign of General Subedei. No general has ever been able to match
his campaign... (conquered the last of the Khwarazmian empire, then
marched north across the Caucasus (something IIRC only 2 other armies
in the history of the world have done successfully) subduing all states
in his wake, dispersed the steppe empires to the north of that, then he
crossed the frozen Russian rivers and defeated a Russian army 13 times
large with very few casualties before heading east again.
4)Cannae – Though Austerlitz is a close second, I’m sure many would
consider this the greatest single tactical masterstroke in the history.
Everyone has dreamed of since. It is consider the “Holy
Grail” by military commanders. Many have tried it, while only
a few have succeeded. It is still studied in institutions today. The
battle is a cliché, and for a good reason.
5) The Alamo: 300 Texans withheld a entire Mexican force for 13 days.
Their Heroic defense served as a beacon for Texas Independence, thus
Remember the Alamo became a famous war-cry for many Texan
leaders. Thermolpoley comes a close second. Both are characterized by
incredible valor in almost certain death
6) China vs. Japan: 1,220 years. Not even Greece and Persia can match
that. Italy and Germany has gone down, and risen up a lot, but China
and Japan has stayed consistent since 780 B.C., and there’s still some
opposition till this day!
7) The battle of Bull Run: The first time that the Union and
Confederate infantry clashed. The D.C. politicians and spectators rode
out thirty miles to see the splendid victory of the Union against the
rabble of the South, expecting them to scatter and flee. To their
surprise, they fled. There was a trail of lunch baskets and bonnets all
the way to Washington. At least one Congressman was captured hiding
behind a tree. LOL
8) Yorktown: LOL, what can I see, I’m patriotic. 8 years of hard-fought freedom, and what do you have? REJOICE!!!
9)Hitler's Invasion of Russia: This proved to be Hitler’s greatest
error. Engaging in a unsuccessful second front an undefeated Britain
and a mobilized America at his rear.
10) Everything: Call me a 'Generalist' (Means I know a lot of nothings.
IMHO). I enjoy the Hannibalic War very much though, it was the closest
that the Ancient War ever came to a World War, nearly encompassing the
entire of Europe and North Africa.
|
Replies:
Posted By: Subotei
Date Posted: 15-Mar-2005 at 03:36
china vs japan?
wat kind of rivalry was there?the only time they fought was the imjiin war
greatest rivalry has got to be French vs England,mongols vs china or persia vs greece
------------- Get inside the enemys thoughts capitalise on their fears.
|
Posted By: Subotei
Date Posted: 15-Mar-2005 at 03:39
the greatest error was not invading russia as hitler predicted it would fall like a crummy house.hitlers error was controlling the army personally and making bad decision after bad decision in russia.(battle of kiev etc) + by the time of normandy russsia was going to win against germany anyway
------------- Get inside the enemys thoughts capitalise on their fears.
|
|