Your Army

Message Share Topic Printable Version Google Delicious Digg StumbleUpon Windows Live Yahoo Bookmarks reddit Facebook MySpace Newsvine Furl Topic Search Topic Options Post Reply Create New Topic

canon394;

True logistics back then were simpler, but even then
generally most armys were equipped in reletivly standard ways. The manner of
supply of archers and slingshot men are different, the procedures for fabricating
are completely different, for spears you need wood and tips of a different
type than arrows. Unless the equipment is standadised its very unlikely they
can sustain a campiagn for long. THough I'll accept that in many cases it was
only for a few battles that an army was raised.

I’d say you are still vastly overstating the logistical
issues involved. A slinger needs what a sling and either rocks or lead bullets.
Casting lead is hardly difficult, I really doubt that any competent blacksmith
otherwise attacked to an ancient army with the job or making repairing all
types of weapons could not do it – frankly it was likely an apprentice’s job.

For spears or javelins of any type in say the Hellenistic world
the preferred wood was ash or cornel so again are you really suggesting a wood
worker not fabricate rods of different lengths and sizes of poles. 

Overall big invasions in the Ancient world oven featured a
fairly heterogonous mix of troops - take Alexander’s initial invasion force or
the Athenian army sent to Syracuse. 
Alexander’s army offers and even better point since even it’s most
nominally standard units the Macedonian cavalry and infantry – used completely different
arms at different times – javelins, lances, sarissa, spears etc…

Also one should not underestimate the simple fact that ‘living
of the land’ in the ancient world could likely provide very many if not most of
armies needs – not just food. By contrast one is probably not likely to find
Main battle tank parts laying around in a farm….